Aberdeen v St. Johnstone

[dons8321]

McGarry has done reasonably well in the games against Hearts and Celtic but he?s never going to be good enough to be our first choice left back.

I remember Gartenmann getting criticised last season for not being good enough at heading the ball for a centre back and to me Molloy isn?t any better at that than Gartenmann was.Hes younger so hopefully he will improve.

Clarkson scored today but other than that it?s like playing a man down with him most of time,gets pushed off the ball too easily then disappears.His set pieces have been abysmal since he signed permanently.

Nesbit to me looks like he isn?t even trying,he?s a shadow of the player he was at Hibs which is probably why Millwall loaned him to us.Just seems to have a terrible attitude.

McGarry has done reasonably well in the games against Hearts and Celtic but he?s never going to be good enough to be our first choice left back.

I remember Gartenmann getting criticised last season for not being good enough at heading the ball for a centre back and to me Molloy isn?t any better at that than Gartenmann was.Hes younger so hopefully he will improve.

Clarkson scored today but other than that it?s like playing a man down with him most of time,gets pushed off the ball too easily then disappears.His set pieces have been abysmal since he signed permanently.

Nesbit to me looks like he isn?t even trying,he?s a shadow of the player he was at Hibs which is probably why Millwall loaned him to us.Just seems to have a terrible attitude.[/QUOTE]


Thought Jack Milne was our best player today...left back/right back did really well.
We should send Nesbit back to Millwall in Jan., he doesn't really offer us anything up front.
As for Molloy, he does well when the ball is pumped is his direction but really struggles when it's left or right of where he's positioned. Malloy, like Gartenmann, is top of the pops for pass completion...trouble is that it's a bit like watching Narey in the 80s. get the ball, look up, pass it to the keeper. I think he could develop into a good CB but he needs an experienced head about him for the next couple of seasons and that's not Ruby.
God knows why Clarkson is always taking set-pieces...the one late on in the 2nd half when he didn't even clear the first defenders knee was shocking.
Why did we switch Duk to the right wing?, he had their full back on toast.
Oh, Rico, in the SS section T it's dry and cosy!