Hibs at home

[bannon_ftd_83]

**** knows what Goodwin is playing at.

[shedka]

Thought we played well second half an deserved to win the game

We were better tonight than on Saturday

Need to see it again but that var decision seemed terrible, then the blatant corner before they then got the second against run of play

Feels like we were robbed tonight

[Whitfieldarab]

Not great tonight again. I really can't see how Paton and Campbell merit starts,they've been pish so far but not as poor as Manny, he needs dropped but that won't happen as JG likes height in his team for long throw ins in the box.

The thing is Hibs weren't great either and made it 2-1 with their 1st shot of the 2nd half. They were there for the taking but we looked quite happy to plod along again HOPE for a breakthrough. Traps and Middleton deserved at least the last 20 minutes there, this should have been the time for us to go on the front foot but we always look intent on playing it safe.

So frustrating.

[shedka]

Agree about Paton and Campbell so far

Anyone seen a replay of the Dalby goal?

[moicher]

Agree about Paton and Campbell so far

Anyone seen a replay of the Dalby goal?

just saw it on sportscene. Nothing clear and obvious about it other than its a goal. 3 points stolen.

[pertharab]

Thought we played well second half an deserved to win the game

We were better tonight than on Saturday

Need to see it again but that var decision seemed terrible, then the blatant corner before they then got the second against run of play

Feels like we were robbed tonight

Robbed on both of those decisions. For the life of me I can't see any reason to chalk off our goal and if it goes 2-1 we weren't losing that game. Apart from the injustice of the VAR decision the whole carry on of not being able to celebrate a goal until it is clear VAR isn't getting involved or until after it has and the goal is given is squeezing all the joy out of spontaneously celebrating a goal. Hate VAR and wish it was binned for good but it mostly favours the arse cheeks and Scotland won't go it alone in scrapping it unfortunately.

[Chick A Saw]

Agree about Paton and Campbell so far

Anyone seen a replay of the Dalby goal?

Just saw it there! If they cannot tell its offside, there is nothing to say that it hit Dalbys hand. However!

Ive seen Paton a few times now and cannot for the life of me see why he is getting a start.
Strain as well, and yes he was involved in the build up to the cracker from Big Ross, but he seems to have lost his edge and pulled out of a challenge leading to their 2rd.
Campbell, im not sure about?
Manny has lost something as well and made far too many mistakes.

Other than that, Sevelj, Stephenson, Gallagher did well for most of the game, Ferry was a level above, but Ross Graham as MoTM.

While i still back him, i fear there is a bit of the Micky Mellons about Goodwin for the last wee while. While i doubt he will change much, i think he need to replace Manny and Strain and blend in a bit more creativity. VDS or Kai need to come in for Paton and just see if we can create something!

[PT_Arab]

I would love to see the exact footage and pictures that the VAR was using when they decided that they could say definitively that the ball hit Dalby's hand. It wasn't clear enough to say definitively that it was offside or onside, but it was clear that it hit his hand? Away and shyte! I've only seen what they showed on Sportscene so I don't know if that's the same pictures that VAR use - I assume it's not.

Also, what happened to only getting involved if it is a clear and obvious error? There's nothing whatsoever clear and obvious about that.

Then the corner that we should have had, but instead Hibs get a goal kick and go 2-1 up less than 60 seconds later - how come the ref is the only person in the ground that can't see it's come off the Hibs player last?

Having said all that, bad decisions don't excuse our awful defending for their second and third goals* - far too easy for Hibs and all in all a sickening way to slip down to 5th.

*We didn't look too clever for their first either.

[LSArab]

The referee and VAR stole those 3 points

What a massive decision and no way that was a handball

[JUSTaway]

Must have taken them about 6 mins to disallow a goal for no reason. Up there, or down there with the Curtis main decision.