Yes, in a way, ours is a positive motivation whilst theirs is a negative one and you'd hope ours is stronger because of that.

As for Barnes, he runs into trouble far too often-he needs a better footballing brain to go with his undoubted ability (although, on that, he could do less of over-hitting the ball or putting it just behind players).

Gordon on the left and Murphy on the right is the way I'd go.