Quote Originally Posted by Old_time_miller View Post
You forget that Scott found 3 great keepers, Semi A, Barlaser, Ogbene, Rathbone, Smith, Reg, Tree…..need I go on?

Under Evans, it wasn’t his remit. Scott finds players of type and costs he is asked to find. The fault is that and also perhaps no warne to vet the character.
You need to look at finances. A big bearing.
It is very difficult to know whether Rob Scott does a good job or not. He is a tool to be used by the manager, not a decision maker.

If he was given the task of signing 16 players on bottom end of league 2 money, has he done a poor job?

If the manager asks for a creative midfielder and he gives a number of options, highlights one of which is extremely injury prone, but the manager signs Josh Benson anyway, has he done a poor job?

It would seem he also highlighted Ryan One as a potential signing this season, who is about to get a league medal, whereas we ended up with Biachieri instead. How many other did he put under the managers nose weren't signed?