Transfer rumour thread 19/20

[stokearab]

................Benji............
Smith Connolly Reynolds Sporle
......Gauld Butcher Harkes......
.....Clark Shankland Safranko...

Win every game 9-3

[offshore_arab83]

Deniz signed.

no one to be negative (nae laughing) but the keeper situation is most definitely our weak point, cannot belive we have not strengthened. silly move IMO
https://www.dundeeunitedfc.co.uk/new...YEAR-DEAL.html

[TerryTheTerror]

I think he's a very decent keeper and we now have two of those on the books.

[offshore_arab83]

in other news we're now linked with Stevie May, if, we can offload big Sow

Hold on i'll get my car keys, what airport are you going to Osman???

https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/spo...en-exit-looms/

[stokearab]

in other news we're now linked with Stevie May, if, we can offload big Sow

Hold on i'll get my car keys, what airport are you going to Osman???

https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/spo...en-exit-looms/

I wonder who's telling the Sun "they want him off the wage bill" or just makey up. I would fly from Spain to drive him to his airport of choice

[offshore_arab83]

if he was that decent why did we let him go and bring in Laidlaw?

What about all the howlers Benji had prior to the playoffs? are they forgotten about now?

What about everyone who was screaming for a new keeper, few good games and its all forgotten about.

Nah sorry, MASSIVE NO fae me.

[thefutureistangerine4]

if he was that decent why did we let him go and bring in Laidlaw?

What about all the howlers Benji had prior to the playoffs? are they forgotten about now?

What about everyone who was screaming for a new keeper, few good games and its all forgotten about.

Nah sorry, MASSIVE NO fae me.

Kind of prefer RN's judgement to yours so reckon this is probably a decent signing. In the few games I have seen him play I was pretty impressed. May end the season as first choice. Two decent keepers though now so thumbs up for me.

[Whitfieldarab]

if he was that decent why did we let him go and bring in Laidlaw?

What about all the howlers Benji had prior to the playoffs? are they forgotten about now?

What about everyone who was screaming for a new keeper, few good games and its all forgotten about.

Nah sorry, MASSIVE NO fae me.

It's a difficult one this, like you say Seigrist was culpable for a few howlers but like McMullan he came on to a game in the last dozen or so games. I just hope goalie coach is teaching him to command his 6 yard box in pre season.

Not overly happy he'll be our no1 but it would've been better if we brought in a better goalie with Benji as back up.

[bobafett]

if he was that decent why did we let him go and bring in Laidlaw?

What about all the howlers Benji had prior to the playoffs? are they forgotten about now?

What about everyone who was screaming for a new keeper, few good games and its all forgotten about.

Nah sorry, MASSIVE NO fae me.

It's also worth remembering he was pretty inexperienced at 1st team level before he came to us, and was playing behind an unsettled back 4 for a good chunk of the time. Continuity is really important to build an understanding between a keeper and the centre-halves. That was a big part of the reason he started to settle down and look like a decent keeper towards the end of the season. I don't see the point in disrupting that and going back to square one now. Let's face it, anyone who is willing to come to us will be, by definition, either flawed or untested, just by virtue of the pond we're fishing in. He'll still have mistakes in him but he's a big, solid laddie and has plenty of potential to improve.

[offshore_arab83]

i dont rate either and never have, and short memories for most on here who never rated Benji either!