Graeme Shinnie

[BogBrush1903]

I think in an ideal world the club would announce between the semi-final and final of the Scottish Cup. The negative news about Shinnie offset with the Cup Final build up. Therefore, I can understand why they haven't announced it yet...But he's definitely leaving so we should really stop with the comparisons to the Logan situation a couple of years ago.

[RedStarTorphins]

I think in an ideal world the club would announce between the semi-final and final of the Scottish Cup. The negative news about Shinnie offset with the Cup Final build up. Therefore, I can understand why they haven't announced it yet...But he's definitely leaving so we should really stop with the comparisons to the Logan situation a couple of years ago.

To be fair, there's only one poster that's comparing the Shinnie situation to that of Logan.

[BogBrush1903]

To be fair, there's only one poster that's comparing the Shinnie situation to that of Logan.

And it is to that poster I'm directing my discontentment at...I'm just being inclusive by using 'we'

[afc1903mad]

To be fair, there's only one poster that's comparing the Shinnie situation to that of Logan.

To be fair, the same was said of McLean going to SevCo and that didn’t happen either.
The Logan comparison is because there is still the potential he could re-sign.

[RedStarTorphins]

To be fair, the same was said of McLean going to SevCo and that didn’t happen either.
The Logan comparison is because there is still the potential he could re-sign.

A more accurate reply would be "the same was said about McLean leaving"...and he did.
Shinnie is gone, just a question of where.
If it's England, good luck to him.

[afc1903mad]

A more accurate reply would be "the same was said about McLean leaving"...and he did.
Shinnie is gone, just a question of where.
If it's England, good luck to him.

No, we have two recent examples.
Logan who was going back to England to be with his family, Brentford amongst others was touted IIRC. He didn’t leave and re-signed in July.
Possibly wee Sam was a major influencer, but he didn’t leave.

McLean was signed on a pre-contract to the Huns, even before the window for many on here. Yes he left, but not to them.

I think Shinnie is possibly 90% certain to leave, probably to Luton, Sunderland or maybe even Derby (if their not promoted) as some suggest today, but I don’t believe it’s a done deal yet, so not absolute certain he’s leaving.

By all accounts it sounds like the club have made him an offer that we cannot top, so I believe the club have done everything they can.
It’s up to the player and we’ll see where he ends up in the summer when all the clubs interested know their budget.

[blowupsheep]

To be fair, there's only one poster that's comparing the Shinnie situation to that of Logan.

and I wonder who that poster might be

[afc1903mad]

and I wonder who that poster might be

Reminds me of the Logan situation.

[blowupsheep]

I'll give you that one pal, that was quite quick and in fairness quite funny.

I do personally believe he will be offski

[afc1903mad]

I think in an ideal world the club would announce between the semi-final and final of the Scottish Cup. The negative news about Shinnie offset with the Cup Final build up. Therefore, I can understand why they haven't announced it yet...But he's definitely leaving so we should really stop with the comparisons to the Logan situation a couple of years ago.

What fact do you have that he is definitely leaving.
It’s an extremely plausible scenario, but not a given.