Aberdeen's penalty yesterday

[manofsteel]

Are any of the Tim's going to admit that it should have been given?

Why would they if they thought it wasn't? As for the incident where was ambrose supposed to go? The boy pushed the ball way past him then jumped into him, sometimes you get them sometimes you dont.

[Alternative_Poster]

I've only seen one report which said it wasn't a penalty (Sunday Mail) and the rest agree with my opinion.

Also the vast majority of posters (non OF) on another site say it was a penalty.

The only folk I've seen arguing against have been Tims. I just want to know if any view it without their green tinted glasses.


Edit: I'm not saying that football fans will ever be completely unbiased (including myself) but Tim's do seem to be worse than most for never seeing a situation honestly.

[manofsteel]

I've only seen one report which said it wasn't a penalty (Sunday Mail) and the rest agree with my opinion.

Also the vast majority of posters (non OF) on another site say it was a penalty.

The only folk I've seen arguing against have been Tims. I just want to know if any view it without their green tinted glasses.

Im not wearing glasses of any kind, if i thought it was a stonewaller i would say it was, i dont think it was a penalty, my opinion i know, and it may fly in the face of the dons fans and others,but thats it. :/






Lol, now im being dishonest, you do realise we won 5-2 dont you, i have no reason to be.

[CoveKreep]

Lol, now im being dishonest, you do realise we won 5-2 dont you, i have no reason to be.

Our previously reliable defence was worryingly cut to ribbons; however we seemed to create a few chances ourselves and if it goes 3-3, especially if the offence was deemed clear goalscoring opportunity - things may have been different.

A pivotal moment possibly, and completely bottled by the ref.

[peter_ssb]

I've only seen one report which said it wasn't a penalty (Sunday Mail) and the rest agree with my opinion.

Also the vast majority of posters (non OF) on another site say it was a penalty.

The only folk I've seen arguing against have been Tims. I just want to know if any view it without their green tinted glasses.

Im not wearing glasses of any kind, if i thought it was a stonewaller i would say it was, i dont think it was a penalty, my opinion i know, and it may fly in the face of the dons fans and others,but thats it. :/






Lol, now im being dishonest, you do realise we won 5-2 dont you, i have no reason to be.[/quote]

Personally I was ****ed off with Hayes, that he did not play vernon in, he was in acres of space, and better placed for a clear goal scoring chance.

As for Pen - it was a strikers run. He made it impossible for Ambrose not to bring him down. That d

[Alternative_Poster]

The pjms and well will not play as offensively as Celtic.

I think we'll struggle. Best case is that the jutes have given up on 3rd and will not be wanting any injuries before the final.

We need a win tomorrow. Good end to the season though. Everything to play for. Makes a change.

The other end of the table is tight as well.

[pwlp]

Total pen, red card = changed game. Ref bottled it. No surprise at The Girodome mind. Most ref's don't have the bottle, even in front of a reduced crowd.

[RedStarTorphins]

Brines is an absolute abomination. I'm not basing this on just Aberdeen games I've witnessed, he's a complete nightmare. Pretty much sums up the sfa this clown.

I'd like to hope he's not biased...just completely and utterly inept.

This was the same ref that never gave us a penalty at Pittodrie against Hearts when one of their players stopped the ball on the line with his hand...red card and a penalty...
we all saw his ineptitude at Parkhead on Saturday...

This is also the same ref that gave a penalty to St Mirren against Motherwell when the ball hit McManus in the face.

He's just incompetent and the SFA should be ashamed having such a clown refereeing big games in this country.

What exactly do the Referee Supervisors do?

[CB_1874]

It was a penalty all day long. And so was Killie's claim v Hearts yesterday.

[ZombieSkelper]

It was a penalty and it wasn't given, tough shyte.