I wonder if all those people who who were dead set against Liam 'Nobel' Noble coming back would have held that view if they had known the alternative. Fair enough, I haven't seen him play, and, as we know from proven published experts, past form documented in Wikipedia is no guide to future perfromances, but those who have seen him say he can trap a ball 25 yards (for example). Forgive me if I am not convinced. Spoilt brat that I am, I was brought up on Masson, but someone like Bishop would do me fine.