+ Visit West Bromwich Albion FC Mad for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results
Page 4 of 4 FirstFirst ... 234
Results 31 to 36 of 36

Thread: Trade or University

  1. #31
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    15,468
    Quote Originally Posted by mickd1961 View Post
    Back in the 70’s we had to do our subject choices from blocks like you explain Abbo.

    This forced me to choose doing German which was absolutely pointless to me along with choosing a science which was utterly pointless.

    What I actually needed was double the amount of Commerce and Business Studies lessons and more Maths lessons.

    My eldest daughter was very artistic and she would’ve gained greatly from more focus on that area of her education.

    With a lot of kids it’s very obvious by 11 years of age as to where their strengths are and the direction they should head but they are forced into doing pointless learning.

    Metalwork, woodwork, sciences etc were completely wasted on me.

    History and Geography were subjects I enjoyed but weren’t particularly talented at but have been useful in general life terms.

    My syllabus should’ve been,

    English Language

    English Literature

    Mathematics

    Commerce

    Business

    Computer Studies

    PE ( lots of additional PE )

    Glad to hear your son is doing so well Abbo and you’re so right about plasterers, this is a £100k to £150k a year trade now for anyone willing to get their hands dirty and work hard.

    In many trades it’s a one man band and in a posh area a trade would earn anything which is good from 180 to 300 a day. The average for plasterers would be approx 200 a day. To earn 150K a year a plasterer would need to earn approx 550 quid a day and work every single one of the 261 approx working days. Never in a million years is this possible. 250 a day is a good wage for a trade and unless they don’t like their family - holidays would not be paid for so previous earnings would need to cover this! Then who’s paying for the pension - bonus - share save - company car. Most self employed can’t be unwell so things like flu and Covid they would just have to carry on or like holidays - subsidise this from previous earnings.

    Students who drop out of uni would mostly never pay back any debt as you don’t start paying back a loan until 27K. Sadly none of our packers or warehouse staff are on anything like 27K otherwise we wouldn’t survive.

  2. #32
    Join Date
    Jul 2020
    Posts
    2,589
    Quote Originally Posted by mickd1961 View Post
    Horses for courses.

    Since Blair’s “education, education, education” mantra we’ve had far too many people going to university in the U.K.

    Kids going for a four year p I s s up and a “gap year”........absolute f u c k I n gnonsense in my eyes, an excuse to do f u c k all until you’re in your mid 20’s.

    Too many worthless degrees in origami and yogurt knitting, too many doing degrees with no idea what they’re actually aiming to achieve as a career.

    I don’t like the modern trend of people being able to leapfrog their way to the top reaches of a business or organisation based on bits of paper, it’s been a disaster for the policing in the U.K. for example.

    It can lead to to people having a superior and jumped up view of themselves, the level of pomposity I’ve come across in some graduates in my industry has been breathtaking.

    In general the graduates have been the biggest fools and wastes of space I’ve come across whereas the best people are the ones who’ve worked their way up from the bottom and have a real feel for their industry and their company.

    Recently I’ve taken on my first ever graduate with a master degree, it hasn’t gone well so far.

    He’s struggled to comprehend and adapt to an eight hour working day, has to be constantly chased up on tasks and keeps getting caught twiddling his thumbs.

    His attitude has really wound the rest of my staff up, he’s regarded as aloof and superior when he’s actually on our bottom rung.

    He had a really rude awakening when pulled into a meeting and told he had a week to sort himself out.

    If you’re going to be a lawyer, doctor, dentist, vet, rocket scientist etc then yes of course, university is very important but for most it is not.

    If I was leaving school again I’d be in a difficult position, I had no interest in any of those very important technical professions and I also had no interest in working with my hands and so learning a trade wasn’t for me,

    There is no shame in starting at shop floor level in any job in the way that I did, it taught me about real life and real people and how to live on my own wits for 44 years almost now.

    In my opinion there are three paths, university, learning a trade and there’s also getting straight into work.

    Not enough people take the third choice these days, too many are swayed by parents into further education because mummy and daddy are desperate to let all their friends know that Tarquin is at “Uni”.....that’s a word that really gets on my t I t s as well.......everyone is at “Uni” these days.

    Or they go because their best friend is going, too many parents pander to this b o l l o c k s.

    I wish kids and parents had enough sense and awareness to work out when it’s right for their child to choose university.

    None of my three wanted to go and if they had I’d have told them that unless they had a career path in mind I wouldn’t support them, thankfully they all preferred to work and start earning.

    A lot of these grads will end up failing once they get found out at their job or come to the realisation that they can’t cope with the real life stress of it.

    Kids need to be guided into what parents know in their heart is the best avenue for THAT child.

    A builder who I use for work has two kids who went to university who now have amazing jobs in technology and his other son hadn’t the same brain power or intellect but he’s a bloody good builder who’s about to take over the family firm.

    I admire his dad for not pushing him down the same route as his older brothers.

    These are parents who did right by their kids.

    Whatever is best for the individual child and not what’s fashionable is always the best answer.
    Very good post, I would also add tho that some kids need Uni to mature and develop independently away from home, as you said it’s horses for courses, my daughter is studying Law and loves it, one of her mates who is very bright decided to do an engineering apprenticeship instead and stay at home, both good decisions for the individuals.

  3. #33
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    15,468
    Quote Originally Posted by DaveP67 is back! View Post
    Very good post, I would also add tho that some kids need Uni to mature and develop independently away from home, as you said it’s horses for courses, my daughter is studying Law and loves it, one of her mates who is very bright decided to do an engineering apprenticeship instead and stay at home, both good decisions for the individuals.

    Good luck to your daughter Dave. For anyone to trash a good grad scheme is simply bitter!! My daughter through a hard slogged first degree went on a fantastic graduate scheme with a large blue chip company and worked her way up through four promotions. She’s earning now what I could have only dreamed about at that age. She will need zero help or finance from me so proud she can stand on her own two feet. I worked with a graduate for TUI U.K. the largest Tour Operator in the World - David Burling! He was sharper than a knife and now their CEO.

    There of course are idiots in every job and profession but a large company with a dedicated graduate recruitment department invests huge finances to get it right and they usually do!

    More respect for someone who places negative comments about uni or graduates that’s been to Uni or had kids that go or owned a very large blue chip company with a proper graduate scheme. Unless this is the case you have to question the bitterness! I wish I had the opportunities.

    I wish I had private health care or had paid 5 grand rather than wait 2 years on the NHS for a recent operation. Truth is - I was too tight to pay the money so my problem! The moral of the story is within this last paragraph!
    Last edited by baggieal; 17-04-2022 at 03:47 PM.

  4. #34
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    25,448
    Quote Originally Posted by baggieal View Post
    Good luck to your daughter Dave. For anyone to trash a good grad scheme is simply bitter!! My daughter through a hard slogged first degree went on a fantastic graduate scheme with a large blue chip company and worked her way up through four promotions. She’s earning now what I could have only dreamed about at that age. She will need zero help or finance from me so proud she can stand on her own two feet. I worked with a graduate for TUI U.K. the largest Tour Operator in the World - David Burling! He was sharper than a knife and now their CEO.

    There of course are idiots in every job and profession but a large company with a dedicated graduate recruitment department invests huge finances to get it right and they usually do!

    More respect for someone who places negative comments about uni or graduates that’s been to Uni or had kids that go or owned a very large blue chip company with a proper graduate scheme. Unless this is the case you have to question the bitterness! I wish I had the opportunities.

    I wish I had private health care or had paid 5 grand rather than wait 2 years on the NHS for a recent operation. Truth is - I was too tight to pay the money so my problem! The moral of the story is within this last paragraph!
    Who’s trashing a good grad scheme?

    You’re seeing what you want to see and not reading what I’m saying if you’re aiming that at me!

    Some see university and a great education as the answer to everything.

    I don’t, I believe there’s more than one way and it’s down to what’s best for the individual.

    I have a good friend who was desperate for his daughter to have the military career that he wished he’d been able to pursue Al, three years ago whilst on officer training she committed suicide.

    I’ve had a few conversations with Des about the fact he’s so intelligent and yet ended up working on the lorries at Wolverhampton Council........he’ll tell you himself, he just valued a simple life.

    I’ve been the opposite and always been highly driven and look where this has taken me mentally in recent months.

    I’ll wager Des is a happier bloke than me, I respect his approach to life now, maybe that would’ve been better for me.

    Truth be told, it’s impossible to know in your 20’s if your choices have been correct in either educational terms or in careers taken.

    I don’t think you really know yourself and whether you’ve got it right until you’re in your 40’s and 50’s.

    This would be a better conversation 20 years from now I guess once we see how lives and careers actually turn out and we ask our kids at 40 to 50 if they’re happy?

    It took me until 60 to realise how unhappy I was with my life.

  5. #35
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    7,079
    Quote Originally Posted by mickd1961 View Post
    Des is one of the most intelligent and well read people I’ve ever met and he didn’t go anywhere near a university.
    Ok, maybe so, how to prove etc…

    But, hardly an answer to my post, if read it correctly.

    In certain lines of business university education is def not needed and would be OTT maybe, I have no problems with that. Oldest son has not (yet) gone to university, youngest has.

    But, I can’t see any university education being detrimental etc, as one could read and interpret some posts. Of course, could be misunderstood etc… 😉

  6. #36
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    15,468
    Quote Originally Posted by SwedishBaggie View Post
    Ok, maybe so, how to prove etc…

    But, hardly an answer to my post, if read it correctly.

    In certain lines of business university education is def not needed and would be OTT maybe, I have no problems with that. Oldest son has not (yet) gone to university, youngest has.

    But, I can’t see any university education being detrimental etc, as one could read and interpret some posts. Of course, could be misunderstood etc… 😉

    Best post of the thread Tomas! Even those who drop out of uni probably have benefited ie still the experience - maturity - independence etc and don’t have to pay anything until they earn more than 27K if they ever do.

    Everyone to their own and each child is different. There will be one child in one family who will want to go to uni where another child will want a trade or apprenticeship.

    There’s an Indian guy in our street who sends one child to a very selective private school ( no he’s not loaded ) because she’s mega bright and the other child to a state school as she has learning difficulties but equally doing well.

    There’s no right or wrong! What annoys me though is companies with say less than 50 staff who advertise for a graduate which will be a glorified apprenticeship. When I mention graduate schemes I am talking mega blue chip powerful companies who will have a dedicated graduate recruitment dept - usually over 300 applicants for one job. Companies like PWC, Deloitte - TUI U.K. - Large Supermarkets. The TUI U.K. graduate was my staff member years ago and now he’s CEO probably on over 500 grand a year. The Waitrose CEO was a graduate too so I could go on and on.

    I get why some don’t want the pressure though
    In life as Mick mentions. A family member is a very good architect ( again went to uni ) but apart from his drawing board - he has a window cleaning round too! Why - he loves the fresh air - cash payment and it keeps him fit.

    Everyone to their own! Some would not even want a lottery win like myself? Why - money is not everything as seen many who are loaded who are mean and miserable.

Page 4 of 4 FirstFirst ... 234

Forum Info

Footymad Forums offer you the chance to interact and discuss all things football with fellow fans from around the world, and share your views on footballing issues from the latest, breaking transfer rumours to the state of the game at international level and everything in between.

Whether your team is battling it out for the Premier League title or struggling for League survival, there's a forum for you!

Gooners, Mackems, Tractor Boys - you're all welcome, please just remember to respect the opinions of others.

Click here for a full list of the hundreds of forums available to you

The forums are free to join, although you must play fair and abide by the rules explained here, otherwise your ability to post may be temporarily or permanently revoked.

So what are you waiting for? Register now and join the debate!

(these forums are not actively moderated, so if you wish to report any comment made by another member please report it.)



Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •