Transfer rumour thread 19/20

[bobafett]

Totally agree, Robson is better than Booth or at least on a par with plenty time to improve, Shankland only started scoring regular in the last couple years so he improved from 21 to 23

Booth has been bog standard for years and that's having peaked already

As for Bouhenna, good player on the ball adverb he has time, not played enough to have missed him though, he was injured for a while why the broken nose. We won most of our games second half of the season without him with Reynolds Connolly at the back and Butcher Harkes in cm

So if he wants to leave, thanks for your efforts Rachid and all the best in Romania or Saudi etc

I still think Butcher being fit is absolutely key, he gives us a steel that we never had before, we don't get out fought or bullied against the likes of ICT etc since he arrived

Yeah, Butcher is ***** for us. We don't really have anything else like him, really.

[Chick A Saw]

Booth, not bothered what happens with him as wasnt sure about him to start with. Between him and Robson, then the latter has improved and has youth on his side and Booth knows all too well where the treatment table is.

Bouhenna i would kinda be gutted if he went as i think he has the potential to be better than Butcher, and is the better option than Connolly. Although he had a mare against Hearts, he did have some positive moments and im sure is probably one of the better midfielders in the Championship. However, if we get a fee and we can get others in then why not.

Not bothered about Sow either as i believe we have better, especially now we have 2 proven at this level high scoring players.

[GUNBOAT]

Very relieved that Robbie has said we do NOT want Stevie May,not really bothered if he ends up being a Funster but would prefer if he went home to ST Johnstone.

[Whitfieldarab]

Totally agree, Robson is better than Booth or at least on a par with plenty time to improve, Shankland only started scoring regular in the last couple years so he improved from 21 to 23



I still think Butcher being fit is absolutely key, he gives us a steel that we never had before, we don't get out fought or bullied against the likes of ICT etc since he arrived

Well Butcher never played in the 3-0 home play off game v ICT and we never got bullied as Bouhenna cruised it.

Butcher does add steel but he is very limited, probably along the lines of Paul Paton.

Give me a player with obvious ability and composure over a hard nut player any day. It's a typical Scottish mentality that we need steel in the centre of midfield plus Bouhenna also gives us valuable cover at CB.

[JamesMcClean]

Well Butcher never played in the 3-0 home play off game v ICT and we never got bullied as Bouhenna cruised it.

Butcher does add steel but he is very limited, probably along the lines of Paul Paton.

Give me a player with obvious ability and composure over a hard nut player any day. It's a typical Scottish mentality that we need steel in the centre of midfield plus Bouhenna also gives us valuable cover at CB.

I think everyone is crying out for Bouhenna to be playing beside Reynolds as opposed to Connolly as his distribution and composure is clearly better. However it seems like the decision has been made unfortunately................

[japanarab]

Very relieved that Robbie has said we do NOT want Stevie May,not really bothered if he ends up being a Funster but would prefer if he went home to ST Johnstone.

Would like a straight May in, Sow out but that’s never gonna happen. I’d love to see Sow get fit and batter in a load alongside Shankland but can’t see it ever happening.

[offshore_arab83]

Rumour on Tek we've offered Sow three months wages to go. Yesterday please. But I'll be accused of not giving the guy a full season to prove his worth.

thats interesting.... as i say, no smoke without fire and all that

[offshore_arab83]

He's a young laddie with a lot of potential. Southampton had scouts up to watch him 3 or 4 times for Christ's sake. Granted he's got a lot to learn but I'd much rather we invest in his potential than spunk wages away on a mediocre player who has proven himself throughout his whole career to be substandard. Hence he was emptied by Hibs and Partick.

Disagree, f uck me how many scouts have came to watch guys and it never developed? Loads! end of the day we should be picking/keeping players who can a job, Robson does not do a job in either position ffs

[offshore_arab83]

Would like a straight May in, Sow out but that’s never gonna happen. I’d love to see Sow get fit and batter in a load alongside Shankland but can’t see it ever happening.

This for me!

[TerryTheTerror]

.... as i say, no smoke without fire and all that

The Internet is one place where there can be huge amounts of smoke and not a fire in sight...