New contracts

[stokearab]

The only divide with Scott Fraser was between clueless and/or boo boy and those that saw the obvious the he was a very good player, would still walk into our side now, that hasn't changed since he left at any point

You're missing the point as is often the case.

The fans who didn't rate Fraser were wrong, the fans who doubt Harkes ability for Top 6 are right. For example if he played v Hibs at Hampden (and I have no idea if he did or didn't) he didn't influence the game did he. He doesn't influence any game. I have never seen him influence a game by dictating play. Ever. He picks a decent pass occasionally, but the number he misses with to hit a good one is considerable, he scores a goal occasionally, but there's a reason we haven't heard about clubs queuing up for his signature.

I think he'll sign an extension or head back to the US.

[TerryTheTerror]

...the fans who doubt Harkes ability for Top 6 are right.

According to you, plenty of Arabs I know don't agree with that.

[Craigbrew]

According to you, plenty of Arabs I know don't agree with that.

Terry , i am asking you nice when was the last really good game before WELL game , you will have to help me out, i am not being nasty, i honestly have no idea when it was, there was few games i forgot he was even playing.. that is deffo no good.. help me out please.

[TerryTheTerror]

Terry , i am asking you nice when was the last really good game before WELL game , you will have to help me out, i am not being nasty, i honestly have no idea when it was, there was few games i forgot he was even playing.. that is deffo no good.. help me out please.

Well according to you it's a struggle but I guess you don't see and appreciate the good he does. For me he's at least a 7/10 every time. But, for instance I think he was easily our best midfielder against the fun at Dens. I know he doesn't score that often but there can't be a player this season who has won us more points with their goals, it's quite incredible how important they have been.

[Craigbrew]

Well according to you it's a struggle but I guess you don't see and appreciate the good he does. For me he's at least a 7/10 every time. But, for instance I think he was easily our best midfielder against the fun at Dens. I know he doesn't score that often but there can't be a player this season who has won us more points with their goals, it's quite incredible how important they have been.

7/10 nah never in a hundred billion years, everyone to their own opinion, BUT 7/10 is not a big score its a huge score, clubs would be queueing up to sign him .. TTT . You have burst my head open with that one.lol

[shedka]

Tarred with a narrative that people have jumped on🤣Is no one allowed a different opinion from you? You seem to think that being over the top positive makes your opinions balanced. No it doesn't.

You've made Harkes seem like Iniesta there. How many bids did we knock back for him in the last window🤨must've been loads based on that wee class montage you've done for him......you should do video for him on YouTube but don't include the bits where he misplaces passes,pulls out of tackles or generally just runs about aimlessly doing fk all👍

Not the most intelligent go at taking the pyss by mentioning Iniesta, passing wasn't mentioned once in the post... Good one that.. Very clever, just highlighting how good a season he has had, he has clearly managed the step up proving those that doubted he could before we got back wrong already (yes he's already proved posters on here wrong) , doesn't look out of place whether we are at Celtic Park, Ibrox, Pittodrie, Easter Road, derbies you name it, you might think they are aimless as you aren't as aware as you think about the game? Pulling out of a tackle, oh yea, like that blood and thunder lower league stuff, cracking, let's get Power from St Mirren instead, that will do the trick.. Misplace a pass, do you think this is La liga? Lol

The narrative comment is there is clearly a bunch of boo boys that don't like Harkes no matter what he does and you get a lot of sheep that jump on those things and some players get singled out a bit like Fraser, he was best player on the park v Motherwell but barely got a mention in here after for example, yet he is always rated by opposition fans after games, have seen that throughout the season many times, there are arabs who do see the obvious quality, he has weaknesses like all our players but his strengths outweigh them and is level of player that is needed to transition towards getting back to being consistent top 4-6 team as we continue to improve, it would likely take something like getting into Europe this season (maybe worth more than winning the cup this season and usually I'd choose cup every time) or next and the money thst brings compared to before to move up a level for us where someone like Harkes would not be seen as an obvious asset and starter

Anyway along with Butch, its not even up for debate anymore that they are good enough for a Utd side pushing for Europe's as that's the reality we can see (Butcher for a second spell) the fact he is coming into his peak years as age wise as LS said it's obviously a no brainer Utd want to extend his stay, the club will love to keep him long term, we might not be able to hang onto him it will be upto him just like Benji

[stokearab]

Not the most intelligent go at taking the pyss by mentioning Iniesta, passing wasn't mentioned once in the post... Good one that.. Very clever, just highlighting how good a season he has had, he has clearly managed the step up proving those that doubted he could before we got back wrong already (yes he's already proved posters on here wrong) , doesn't look out of place whether we are at Celtic Park, Ibrox, Pittodrie, Easter Road, derbies you name it, you might think they are aimless as you aren't as aware as you think about the game? Pulling out of a tackle, oh yea, like that blood and thunder lower league stuff, cracking, let's get Power from St Mirren instead, that will do the trick.. Misplace a pass, do you think this is La liga? Lol

The narrative comment is there is clearly a bunch of boo boys that don't like Harkes no matter what he does and you get a lot of sheep that jump on those things and some players get singled out a bit like Fraser, he was best player on the park v Motherwell but barely got a mention in here after for example, yet he is always rated by opposition fans after games, have seen that throughout the season many times, there are arabs who do see the obvious quality, he has weaknesses like all our players but his strengths outweigh them and is level of player that is needed to transition towards getting back to being consistent top 4-6 team as we continue to improve, it would likely take something like getting into Europe this season (maybe worth more than winning the cup this season and usually I'd choose cup every time) or next and the money thst brings compared to before to move up a level for us where someone like Harkes would not be seen as an obvious asset and starter

Anyway along with Butch, its not even up for debate anymore that they are good enough for a Utd side pushing for Europe's as that's the reality we can see (Butcher for a second spell) the fact he is coming into his peak years as age wise as LS said it's obviously a no brainer Utd want to extend his stay, the club will love to keep him long term, we might not be able to hang onto him it will be upto him just like Benji

Genuine question then

Do you think any of these clubs would be interested in signing him

Celtic
Rangers
Hearts
Hibs
Aberdeen
Championship England

If you're honest with yourself the answer is no

[Craigbrew]

Is football or any sport a hell of a lot about being consistent, i did like Frazer , he had the talent be a lot better than i thought he ended up, maybe coaching maybe never worked hard enough, maybe never wanted it enough, but loads games went missing, i also liked Harkes but he is deff a soft touch has got a great pass in him, but when is the next one, He had a really good game Well most of us all said it, he had a great game, when was his last assist can someone tell me , for your main midfielder and i have no idea when it was is wrong..we have scored 21 goals and we are 3/4 through this season, and 35 think all last season ..that is utter and totally pathetic.. Like any player start playing consistent any fans will back you in any team , go missing and this is what happens, you end up some thinking hes is doing great job others like me, whens his next good game.. Harkes it is on you, got 12 games left to prove you can play consistent..go and show us what you can do.

[stokearab]

Just out of interest I checked Arab Archive for the Cup Semi v Hibs
The midfield was Fuchs Harkes Butcher and Clark. Harkes was subbed off on 60 for Pawlett

This was a chance to reach a cup final but our midfield never turned up. We couldn't keep the ball and create any sustainable pressure on Hibs. Nothing.

Harkes is a great guy judging by all his interviews but we need better quality if we want to get to the next level and that includes Butcher and Pawlett by the way. Our midfield has been failing us for years. The club decision makers don't appear to agree so my opinion is just that, an opinion.

[Whitfieldarab]

Not the most intelligent go at taking the pyss by mentioning Iniesta, passing wasn't mentioned once in the post... Good one that.. Very clever, just highlighting how good a season he has had, he has clearly managed the step up proving those that doubted he could before we got back wrong already (yes he's already proved posters on here wrong) , doesn't look out of place whether we are at Celtic Park, Ibrox, Pittodrie, Easter Road, derbies you name it, you might think they are aimless as you aren't as aware as you think about the game? Pulling out of a tackle, oh yea, like that blood and thunder lower league stuff, cracking, let's get Power from St Mirren instead, that will do the trick.. Misplace a pass, do you think this is La liga? Lol

The narrative comment is there is clearly a bunch of boo boys that don't like Harkes no matter what he does and you get a lot of sheep that jump on those things and some players get singled out a bit like Fraser, he was best player on the park v Motherwell but barely got a mention in here after for example, yet he is always rated by opposition fans after games, have seen that throughout the season many times, there are arabs who do see the obvious quality, he has weaknesses like all our players but his strengths outweigh them and is level of player that is needed to transition towards getting back to being consistent top 4-6 team as we continue to improve, it would likely take something like getting into Europe this season (maybe worth more than winning the cup this season and usually I'd choose cup every time) or next and the money thst brings compared to before to move up a level for us where someone like Harkes would not be seen as an obvious asset and starter

Anyway along with Butch, its not even up for debate anymore that they are good enough for a Utd side pushing for Europe's as that's the reality we can see (Butcher for a second spell) the fact he is coming into his peak years as age wise as LS said it's obviously a no brainer Utd want to extend his stay, the club will love to keep him long term, we might not be able to hang onto him it will be upto him just like Benji

Wow......and relax.

After all that absolute pysh the main thing is that along with the rest of our glorious midfield your poster boy Harkes is creating tons of chances and we are free flowing every game and the entertainment is aff the scale. He is part of a midfield that creates hee haw.

Here's a stat for you. See when we lost 6 games in a row, Harkes played in 5 of them and the 1 he missed was Sevco away when we played well with the young anes😳

He has the ability to be a good player, no doubt there but he has too many games where he is anonymous and hides when the going gets tough.