Var

[Arabknight]

100% this. You don?t fix refereeing by adding more refereeing.

Here?s an idea; let?s bin VAR and put the money towards bringing back the reserve league so we can actually nurture our young players and keep fringe players match fit.

100 percentage agree with this 👍

[Arabknight]

Its never a foul its a goalkeeping error.If Dalby does exactly the same at the other end we would all be going mental if it was chalked off by VAR.No doubt about it though VAR has cost us penalties at both ends in the Derbies.Against Killie our players cost us two certain goals from mistakes and bad judgement from six yards out.That;s why we lost a game we should comfortably have won.

I said it at the time and continue to agree GB. It?s wasn?t a foul Walton was at fault. He does nothing to protect himself when he jumps for the ball and as you say we if the shoe was in the other foot we wld be shouting for it.

[Sutherland Arab]

I've seen a few people saying "keepers are too protected" when discussing the foul by Watkins on Walton. But if that's the case, why wasn't this one given as a foul like all the others? It's a clear foul, he runs several yards, throws his arm over Walton, and barges into him. Some people are saying Walton should have been stronger in that situation, and maybe that's true, but it's irrelevant when this type of challenge is always given as a foul. The inconsistency from these officials is honestly shocking.

If anyone is going to take advantage of this new leniency when it comes to jumping with the keeper, its Goodwin and this United side. Let's see how consistent the officials are moving forward.

Spot on
It's a foul and will continue to be one 99% of the time. That is the problem and good on the club backing out of the highly dubious KMI panel.

[shedka]

Open goal today discuss the Dalby goal

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=gBhYEzyUY5A

48m25s in it, Faddys reaction when shown it by Ferry says it all

[Arabdownsouth]

**** me! Even that specky c*nt Foster says it should have been a goal. I'm still f*cking raging tbh and haven't posted till now because I'm out of f*cking words for the state of our game. Absolute blatant f*cking cheatery! Nothing else! I'd put a years salary on that goal not even being questioned at either Ibrox or Parkhead for the home side. Time to bin these useless,crooked,cheating bast*rds and use the money to employ neutral refs from Scandinavia or f*cking Lichtenstein or somewhere before VAR drives the fans out of football altogether.

F*cking cheating c*nts!

Did I mention I'm still raging btw?

[geofoxposse]

Here?s an idea; let?s bin VAR and put the money towards bringing back the reserve league so we can actually nurture our young players and keep fringe players match fit.

this will also give more proper match time to officials to try to work out how to officiate.

However Ive always said a levy on the gate of 50p would more than pay for European or other registered refs to come and do matches.
In fact one international panel would make this possible for all.

[JUSTaway]

In 40 years of watching utd, I've seen more than my fair share of dreadful refereeing decisions, including the worst ever - the non paddy Connolly goal, numerous costly cup final decisions, the Simon Murray non penalty red card play off decision, the ciftci Inverness fiasco, but I'm asking myself, how the hell in the short time with var, we've actually managed to get maybe two of the top 5 at least, bad decisions in my time of supporting utd- the Curtis main dive and goal midweek chopped off.

[Yeats 62]

The word on the Pavie is that the VAR screen wasn't working before the game and the teams and Ref were told this. But.......instead of agreeing that this could end up a problem and deciding to play the game without it (like some cup matches) The (paid) officials went on regardless.

The first VAR call was announced at the match as "possible offside" then when the VAR folk couldn't get the lines working it mysteriously then turned in to "possible handball" (meh erse) THEN... with the Ref having no way to check his original decision due to (technical difficulties) he had to accept (blindly) that the "impartial" VAR guys in The Glesgae had spotted something (anything) that he didn't.

As for it getting binned in Scotland, ain't gonna happen. It has been mentioned a few times, that UEFA like it and want it (with better Refs etc) so the SFA will just kiss arse and hope that the experience our Refs have of using our sh*t version of it will get them some lower European games to referee.

I have yet to see, or read anyone that has watched that goal say it hit Sam's hand . Unlike others, we stood up to VAR and it looks like it is coming back big time, to bite our arses.

[beardyface23]

the goal celtic had chalked off last saturday has also been judged wrong. so that's 4,maybe 5 points the spoonburning ****s have gained

[cybershed]

It's a sickened by that decision midweek. If we miss out on third due to that decision (and a guaranteed ?5M to boot) that will be so unfair to the United players.

The best & only way we have to hit back at this injustice is to still get third in the league.

'Mon the shed - we can do this!