Originally Posted by
Aldo1983
McInnes and Clarke implement the Craig Brown Book of Coaching Football very well to be fair. Even Calderwood with us and Smith with Scotland.
You come into a struggling team and play ultra defensive then build from there.
Unfortunately they don't have the capacity to build much further than that. So ultimately they look good compared to the old boss (Remember McGhee™️) but overall, in the long run, we don't really achieve anything other than not being utterly ****e as opposed to just ****e.
So then new guy comes in, he tries to take (whoever it is) that bit further, plays expansive football, tries new things, forward thinking but he's likely to be ****e in the first place or because he doesn't get off to a good start (Kirk Broadfoot, etc doesn't like his fancy new ideas) then we immediately remind ourselves of how "Craig Brown would go to Latvia and get a solid 0-1 when we needed it".
I don't think Hearts would have been any worse off if they stuck with Cathro. They may even have been actually quite good. (Thankfully they are pish).