I've no problem with 'keepers staying on their line and letting the defenders take on the physical stuff, but there has to be decisiveness. He came off his line for Forrest's cross last week, and completely missed it, a really stupid call and action. Whilst not exonerating Arnason for failing to challenge the Tim striker, the 'keeper's presumed shout and movement from his line is a signal that he is 100% confident of taking/punching out the cross. Leighton and Theo were under strict instruction to stay on their line and let 6 and McLeish deal with the nasty stuff outside the 6 yard box, unless they were certain that they had crosses covered.
Woodgate now inspires no confidence from those in front of him as a result. "Fit the ****'s he going to dee next?" is a poor basis for building confidence between the centre halves and the 'keeper.