Next manager

[GUNBOAT]

I've actually just read his texts...he really doesn't miss many does he?? However back on topic if the boy from Tranmere turns you down too will you accept that wee c@nt Dodds with the Agent������

Good morning Peter,i find your input much more amusing than your fellow fan BP.

[jjaflup22]

It’s not simply ‘choosing’ to believe he has changed. Like literally anything in life, you take a standpoint on what evidence is out their to form an opinion or take a stance on something. In this case, the evidence is clear that Mackay has taken all appropriate measures and has been backed by major Equality and Diversity groups. Seven years ago the evidence was that MM was a racist. Now, the evidence is that he has been rehabilitated. As a consequence, I have no issue currently with him as there is no evidence out there to the contrary. Forming ‘opinions’ on people with no current evidence to actually back something up in many ways can be just as bad.

But that's what you're doing?! You have absolutely no evidence to say that he has changed and I have none to say that he hasn't. Anyone can do diversity training etc. but in reality it means absolutely nothing. All that matters to me is that this guy had a bad reputation, whether in the past or currently, and I don't want that to be associated with United.

[tHeArAb]

thought of appointing MM is giving me the fear. yeah he maybe scottish but hes never played/managed/coached in scotland in his career. his back to back promotions with Tranmere sound good but one of them he was expected to do. Clearly got a promotion bounce which he took into the league 2 season. his record is decent without being brilliant imo.

Strikes me as a heckingbotham type.

People seem to prefer him due to him not being one of the usual suspects went linked with jobs up here (even though he has been linked with st mirren and killie up here before)

I prefer him because he's a proven winner. He's won leagues, he's won big playoff games. He's Scottish. He still relatively young & hungry, he has an almost 50% win ratio.

[Shedboy1971]

lets be honest not one of us has a scoobie really who will be a success. I am sure Malky has been ruled out now and whilst i dont agree 100% with the outrage on him if Tony decides the issues are too much then agree could do without all the baggage. Micky Mellon all i know about him is he was **** in football manager when i took Blackpool to european glory and premier league dominance. Could i sell the prick mellon , no. He won all these trophies and never played a game. For that alone i am not sure i can forgive him so its a no from me.

[JamesMcClean]

But that's what you're doing?! You have absolutely no evidence to say that he has changed and I have none to say that he hasn't. Anyone can do diversity training etc. but in reality it means absolutely nothing. All that matters to me is that this guy had a bad reputation, whether in the past or currently, and I don't want that to be associated with United.

Absolutely no evidence? Did you actually read my post?

[darrenshedtastic]

I prefer him because he's a proven winner. He's won leagues, he's won big playoff games. He's Scottish. He still relatively young & hungry, he has an almost 50% win ratio.

No doubt his record down south is good. only won league once. gets teams up via playoffs alot. (nothing wrong with that just stating). imo the teams he has got promoted from the conference into the league system down south are teams who would be expected to be in the league. Fleetwood and Tranmere.

Dont get me wrong if he gets appointed then ill back him but just not keen on it im afraid. like everyone, you get vibes about managers or appointments and this one doesnt give me a good vibe. reminds me of the mixu appointment. :/

[offshore_arab83]

thought of appointing MM is giving me the fear. yeah he maybe scottish but hes never played/managed/coached in scotland in his career. his back to back promotions with Tranmere sound good but one of them he was expected to do. Clearly got a promotion bounce which he took into the league 2 season. his record is decent without being brilliant imo.

Strikes me as a heckingbotham type.

People seem to prefer him due to him not being one of the usual suspects went linked with jobs up here (even though he has been linked with st mirren and killie up here before)

for the record and putting it out there now i do NOT want the mellon

[tHeArAb]

Tbh I'm just glad he's not one of the usual journeyman managers on some kind of Scottish football club merry-go-round. I'm also happy we haven't gone for an up n comer like we have done in years gone by. That's another waste of time.

[offshore_arab83]

i know people are saying managerial appointments are a risk and they are but some are bigger risks than other, Wright for example is a risk but a lesser risk than mellon

[darrenshedtastic]

genuine question, do you think TA knows what hes doing with this appointment? we seem to be all over the place? yeah he wants to speak to people, some who are currently in jobs but we seem to be taking a fair bit of time to get this sorted. (time we don't have). Clearly McClaren was his man but after that didnt happen, we seem to have went back to square one. Now we are still speaking to people?!? surely this should have all been done by now? the Wright comment he made aswell?

i hope he gets the right man in but he seems to be unsure of what to do here.