I'm afraid I agree with the OP. It's a nice idea to try to play football the 'right' way, but in reality, we need to be able to mix it up. The teams that do well at this level are packed full of runners, they press high and fast, and are well organised. They invariably have an ugly side, which we don't.
The best teams are horrible to play against not because they pass in triangles and kill you with fluid movement, but because they relentlessly close you down and win the 50-50s. Teams like Halifax. We sorely miss a nasty midfielder whose job is to win the ball. Or a nasty anyone. Look at Wright at Torquay - not the best striker in the world but horrible to play against. Certainly not the kind of player Notts would sign though.