Well that's

[Returnofrros]

Before they gave women the gigs they didn’t have National League ex players on as they couldn’t offer insight into the game etc for the man in the street.

They shouldn’t be on the screen as ‘experts’.

Tom Duthie?

Ex Courier guy

Twa teams one street podcast.

Thinks he's Dave Allan level of irony but isnae.

[islaydarkblue]

Basically saying it should be the most qualified person for the job re punditry and women (ex pros) don't have the same insight as male ex pros.

The BBC Scotland one ( Leanne Creighton) I don't mind so much as she's no pretending to know about pl football.

The other thing I've not seen is a female presenter or interviewer do anything different from the men that do the job......it's just the same inane crap.

I know he's not everyone's cup of tea and he's a raving lefty loony but Micheal Stewart I have a bit of time for......fairly consistent.....knows theres a bit more to Scottish football than Rantic.

Cannae stand McFadden, the we'll past sell by dates of Bonner and Miller and any old firm cheerleader ( Sutton and Rae ).

More locally uncle Tom Duthie is a total tit and cran has a puss that says " how long have I got to sit next to this idiot"

Slightly different topic but Lyle Cameron is a natural in front of camera, articulate, knowledge and courteous.

He is quite right. The most qualified person should be appointed for the job.
However the BBC has to be seen to be ‘squeaky clean’ and have equality amongst football pundits and commentators.
The women pundits and commentators should concentrate on the women’s football matches and leave the men to be pundits and commentators on the male football matches.

[Dodbroon]

Reckon it's blatant ***ism to say women shouldn't be involved in broadcasting men's football. Shocking behaviour imo!! I wouldn't have them doing analysis though on any of that stuff that they might not understand. Perfectly reasonable though to have the women presenting the shows and doing the sports news stuff etc. so long as they are tidy looking bits of stuff, no old boots allowed! As I said I won't hold with any of this discrimination stuff; a bad show the lot of it.

[Deeranged]

Reckon it's blatant ***ism to say women shouldn't be involved in broadcasting men's football. Shocking behaviour imo!! I wouldn't have them doing analysis though on any of that stuff that they might not understand. Perfectly reasonable though to have the women presenting the shows and doing the sports news stuff etc. so long as they are tidy looking bits of stuff, no old boots allowed! As I said I won't hold with any of this discrimination stuff; a bad show the lot of it.

You don't say much my friend, but when you do it's to the point, and I salute you for it.

Copyright Big Dan Teague