Var

[Returnofrros]

We benefitted yesterday but I'm sick to the back teeth of it.

Over 7000 folk and both managers didn't know who they were checking pen for.

VAR has to be taken out completely or limited.

I'd say limit to offside at a goal, check pen when given.......not if not given and serious foul play.......thats it........and serious foul play and penalties only to be viewed at normal speed.....freeze frame I can accept for offside but pens and foul play ....no more next season.

[davydook]

We benefitted yesterday but I'm sick to the back teeth of it.

Over 7000 folk and both managers didn't know who they were checking pen for.

VAR has to be taken out completely or limited.

I'd say limit to offside at a goal, check pen when given.......not if not given and serious foul play.......thats it........and serious foul play and penalties only to be viewed at normal speed.....freeze frame I can accept for offside but pens and foul play ....no more next season.

Shambolic to say the least.
When it's working properly.

[Deeranged]

We benefitted yesterday but I'm sick to the back teeth of it.

Over 7000 folk and both managers didn't know who they were checking pen for.

VAR has to be taken out completely or limited.

I'd say limit to offside at a goal, check pen when given.......not if not given and serious foul play.......thats it........and serious foul play and penalties only to be viewed at normal speed.....freeze frame I can accept for offside but pens and foul play ....no more next season.

I knew the penalty was going to us because I saw it happen. The rest I agree with - total shambles and our poor referees are now depending on it.

[Returnofrros]

Imagine the scenario where st j had scored on the break !!!!.

I'd assume if he then gives pen their "goal" wud then have to have been ruled out.

Or what if they break and it's a last man foul and off......it's then ruled out again as penalty wud supercede it.

You can see one almighty rammy coming........you can just feel it.

[Deeranged]

Imagine the scenario where st j had scored on the break !!!!.

I'd assume if he then gives pen their "goal" wud then have to have been ruled out.

Or what if they break and it's a last man foul and off......it's then ruled out again as penalty wud supercede it.

You can see one almighty rammy coming........you can just feel it.

Pretty sure there was a goal disallowed in an African Nations Cup semi last week and a penalty given by VAR at the other end. The ordering off possibility is an interesting one, how can someone be through with a goal scoring opportunity if the game should have been stopped - would be total confusion and our refs wouldn't have a clue what to do.

[noahrab]

Imagine the scenario where st j had scored on the break !!!!.

I'd assume if he then gives pen their "goal" wud then have to have been ruled out.

Or what if they break and it's a last man foul and off......it's then ruled out again as penalty wud supercede it.

You can see one almighty rammy coming........you can just feel it.

Happened in Nations Cup semi Portugal v Switzerland.

Penalty call for Swiss ignored, Portugal break and are awarded penalty. VAR looks at Swiss incident and awards penalty and cancels out Portuguese one.

2019.

[noahrab]

Pretty sure there was a goal disallowed in an African Nations Cup semi last week and a penalty given by VAR at the other end. The ordering off possibility is an interesting one, how can someone be through with a goal scoring opportunity if the game should have been stopped - would be total confusion and our refs wouldn't have a clue what to do.

Ball is still in play so player would be off.

[davydook]

Ball is still in play so player would be off.

But surely it would have to be overturned as in reality the play is pulled back for the penalty so anything after the penalty incident doesn't come into play.
Unless it was violent conduct.

[Dodbroon]

VAR is an utter shambles. When you combine it with an incompetent wee nyaff of a ref like Munro then shambles turns into chaos. I'd stand the little sh1te down for the rest of the season but the SFA and SPFL will close ranks and nothing will happen. Pathetic!

[Returnofrros]

Happened in Nations Cup semi Portugal v Switzerland.

Penalty call for Swiss ignored, Portugal break and are awarded penalty. VAR looks at Swiss incident and awards penalty and cancels out Portuguese one.

2019.

Good to know.

Here's my mental mind......st j score on break, they go mental, player then runs to crowd and is booked and already on yellow.....sent AFF.

Is that overturned if pen is then awarded to Dundee?

Ball ain't technically in play.