Jack Collinson

[cscar58]

Thoughts on this one please lads? - view external link

[WHU]

good lad to have around but he ain't big enough for the current manager. i called it a long time ago. i said noble may survive with his battling qualities but craft and guile amongst the whu yoof will be kicked to the kerb with toady. would he make it under a FOOTBALL manager? dunno but we won't find out will we, unless we get a FOOTBALL manager and not a percentage over-paid stopball merchant

[Dailly___7]

Never been the same player since his big injury. Great shame because he looked to have a massive future with us.

Probably a Championship player in all honesty.

[Ironworks1]

good lad to have around but he ain't big enough for the current manager. i called it a long time ago. i said noble may survive with his battling qualities but craft and guile amongst the whu yoof will be kicked to the kerb with toady. would he make it under a FOOTBALL manager? dunno but we won't find out will we, unless we get a FOOTBALL manager and not a percentage over-paid stopball merchant

Don't agree with this. There is a spare slot in midfield for a player like him but, bottom line, Allardyce has obviously decided he's not good enough - I agree with that.

You shouldn't confuse how Collison used to be with the player he is now, post injury. Night and Day for me. Very little guile there now, just a willingness to run. He doesn't like a tackle much these days either.

Shame

If your post was about Morrison I might have agreed.

[rednekst]

Shame to say that he is struggling to find his best position.

Sam doesn't have a great deal of time for him as he has Taylor doing a similar job!!

Diame is more attack minded, and stronger. Nolan is first on the team sheet. So not a lot of scope left really.

If the club want to unload him on a permanent basis then the fee will be the talking point.

[IronworksFC]

His injury has had a massive detrimental effect on his career, I also think recovering to fitness and returning with Sam at the helm has not helped either.

Diame has been pretty sh1t this season, would rather see Jack given a go. Diame maybe stronger red, but that doesn't stop him from losing the ball all over the pitch.

[KetterinHammer]

Why are we helping Dave Whelan out FFS

[cscar58]

Cheers all (other than Ketterin - there's always one )

[WHU]

good lad to have around but he ain't big enough for the current manager. i called it a long time ago. i said noble may survive with his battling qualities but craft and guile amongst the whu yoof will be kicked to the kerb with toady. would he make it under a FOOTBALL manager? dunno but we won't find out will we, unless we get a FOOTBALL manager and not a percentage over-paid stopball merchant

Don't agree with this. There is a spare slot in midfield for a player like him but, bottom line, Allardyce has obviously decided he's not good enough - I agree with that.

You shouldn't confuse how Collison used to be with the player he is now, post injury. Night and Day for me. Very little guile there now, just a willingness to run. He doesn't like a tackle much these days either.

Shame

If your post was about Morrison I might have agreed.[/quote]

take your word for it mate, i'm hardly a regul

[Ironworks1]

Can't make the game this week mate

Say hello to Slipper of the Yard from me