Could it happen & when was the last time.

[Lolmorgan]

If Sheff Utd, Sheff W come down & Us, Barnsley & Doncaster stay in Lge 1.I cant recall playing them all in the same league.

[Brin]

Neither can I pal??? Good question that.

[Brin]

If Sheff Utd, Sheff W come down & Us, Barnsley & Doncaster stay in Lge 1.I cant recall playing them all in the same league.

I've just found the answer.....

The last time Sheffield United, Sheffield Wednesday, Doncaster Rovers, Barnsley, and Rotherham United were all in the same league division was during the 1979-80 season.
During this season, all five South Yorkshire clubs competed in the Third Division (which was the third tier of English football at the time). Barnsley, Sheffield United, and Rotherham were all close in the mid-table standings, while Sheffield Wednesday won promotion at the end of the season.

[Lolmorgan]

I cant see Doncaster but Chesterfield there.

[Lolmorgan]

1
Sheffield United
9 6 1 2 13
2
Rotherham United
9 6 0 3 12
3
Millwall
9 4 4 1 12
4
Swindon
9 5 1 3 11
5
Gillingham
8 4 3 1 11
6
Blackpool
9 5 1 3 11
7
Oxford United
8 4 2 2 10
8
Brentford
8 4 2 2 10
9
Colchester United
9 4 2 3 10
10
Chesterfield
9 4 1 4 9
11
Sheffield Wednesday
9 3 3 3 9
12
Hull City
9 2 5 2 9
13
Reading
9 3 3 3 9
14
Barnsley
9 4 1 4 9
15
Southend United
8 3 2 3 8
16
Carlisle United
9 3 2 4 8
17
Grimsby Town
9 3 2 4 8
18
Chester
9 2 4 3 8
19
Wimbledon
9 3 1 5 7
20
Blackburn
9 1 4 4 6
21
Plymouth Argyle
9 2 2 5 6
22
Exeter City
9 3 0 6 6
23
Bury
9 2 1 6 5
24
Mansfield Town
9 2 1 6 5

[Brin]

I cant see Doncaster but Chesterfield there.

......That's what you get copying and pasting pal

[Lolmorgan]

I've just found the answer.....

The last time Sheffield United, Sheffield Wednesday, Doncaster Rovers, Barnsley, and Rotherham United were all in the same league division was during the 1979-80 season.
During this season, all five South Yorkshire clubs competed in the Third Division (which was the third tier of English football at the time). Barnsley, Sheffield United, and Rotherham were all close in the mid-table standings, while Sheffield Wednesday won promotion at the end of the season.

Doncaster was in the 4th Division.

[ScjR]

1951/1952

1/9/1951 Rotherham Utd 2 Doncaster Rovers 0 (Guest, Shaw)
22/9/1951 Sheffield Wednesday 3 Rotherham Utd 5 (Sewell 2, McJarrow) (Tomlinson, Wragg, Shaw 2, Grainger)
13/10/1951 Sheffield Utd 1 Rotherham Utd 0 (Brook)
20/10/1951 Rotherham Utd 4 Barnsley 0 (Tomlinson, Shaw 3)
29/12/1951 Doncaster Rovers 0 Rotherham Utd 3 (Shaw 2, Grainger)
26/1/1952 Rotherham Utd 3 Sheffield Wednesday 3 (Guest, Shaw, Williams) (Woodhead, Sewell, Dooley)
1/3/1952 Rotherham Utd 3 Sheffield Utd 1 (Guest 2, Grainger) (Ringstead)
8/3/1952 Barnsley 0 Rotherham Utd 1 (Rawson)

[Jocksgloves1]

I always thought Dooley scored a hat-trick at Millmoor.

[Lolmorgan]

1951/1952

1/9/1951 Rotherham Utd 2 Doncaster Rovers 0 (Guest, Shaw)
22/9/1951 Sheffield Wednesday 3 Rotherham Utd 5 (Sewell 2, McJarrow) (Tomlinson, Wragg, Shaw 2, Grainger)
13/10/1951 Sheffield Utd 1 Rotherham Utd 0 (Brook)
20/10/1951 Rotherham Utd 4 Barnsley 0 (Tomlinson, Shaw 3)
29/12/1951 Doncaster Rovers 0 Rotherham Utd 3 (Shaw 2, Grainger)
26/1/1952 Rotherham Utd 3 Sheffield Wednesday 3 (Guest, Shaw, Williams) (Woodhead, Sewell, Dooley)
1/3/1952 Rotherham Utd 3 Sheffield Utd 1 (Guest 2, Grainger) (Ringstead)
8/3/1952 Barnsley 0 Rotherham Utd 1 (Rawson)

Thank you, 74yrs ago.

[ScjR]

Opposition players that have scored a hat-trick @ Millmoor

Harold Andrews Lincoln City 19 April 1926
Jimmy Trotter Sheffield Wednesday 06/12/1926 County Cup
Johnny Dent Nottm Forest 11/01/1930 FA Cup
Jacob Parsons Acc Stanley 08/02/1930
Joe Mantle Chester 07/01/1933
Bob Mortimer Acc Stanley 21/12/1935
Albert Brallisford Darlington 02/01/1937
Tommy Davis Oldham Athletic 13/02/1937
Jack Scott Hartlepool United 06/03/1937
Jimmy Kendall Barrow 24/05/1947
John Charles Leeds Utd 19/12/1953
Gordon Turner Luton Town 29/01/1955 FA Cup
Stan Pearson Bury 26/12/1955
Peter Dobbing Blackburn Rovers 04/01/1958 FA Cup
Don Kitchenbrand Sunderland 22/11/1958
Terry Paine Southampton 01/10/1963
Geoff Vowden Birmingham City 11/12/1965
George Jones Bury 09/08/1969
David Ford Sheffield United 06/05/1971 County Cup
Brian Clark Bournemouth 10/10/1972
Alan Mayes Swindon Town 24/02/1979
Ian Banks Barnsley 14/11/1981
Kevin Keegan Newcastle Utd 02/10/1982 FA Cup
Duncan Shearer Huddersfield Town 18/08/1987 League Cup
Tony Thorpe Luton Town 05/04/1997
Kevin Phillips Sunderland 03/01/1998 FA Cup
Lloyd Owusu Brentford 20/02/1999
Akpo Sodge Port Vale 10/03/2007
Tommy Rowe Stockport County 12/02/2008

[Eternal Optimist]

Also,

Tom Eaves Hull City 04/01/20.

[caytonmiller]

Also,

Tom Eaves Hull City 04/01/20.

Doesn't count. At nys. P

[Eternal Optimist]

Doh!