Cardiff Post-Match thoughts.....retire to a safe distance

[Stansmate]

Simples!!! - in the words of the song

? He dunt no wot hes doin ?

[Timbertop]

Just cannot fathom why Hamshaw is still our manager. Expecting him to be sacked tomorrow.

[Townerslovechild]

Had time to mull it over, and on reflection we were still sh*te.
I don't like singling outsourcing players for criticism, but from day 1 I've never really got what McWilliams does,he's not a box to box type, he's not a Gore type,he's not a CDM,not an attacking midfielder either.
Oh yeah...never let Martha take another corner.

[Brin]

Had time to mull it over, and on reflection we were still sh*te.
I don't like singling outsourcing players for criticism, but from day 1 I've never really got what McWilliams does,he's not a box to box type, he's not a Gore type,he's not a CDM,not an attacking midfielder either.
Oh yeah...never let Martha take another corner.

I forgot about them.....add that to his reseme/CV

[Old_time_miller]

Where is the evidence of him being a very good coach ?

Wiles. Douglas.

[Old_time_miller]

Well, reading all.
We are stuck with a back 3, he isn?t going to change it. When he does, one full back is taken off.
We have still, too much deadwood washing up, some removed with young ones who need time.
We have the worst keeper in 50 years of watching.
We have a reserve keeper who is better, can catch a ball, can dive, jump and catch. Gives defence confidence, that from brief cameos.

Hamshaw, wake up.

[Derbymiller]

Wiles. Douglas.

He played Douglas because he had to and then dropped him out of the match day squad when he was fit again to replace him with his new bloke.
Not saying he isn?t a good coach, I think there is evidence from his time with Warne that he has abilities in that role, but in my opinion he isn?t manager material. However my opinion like your opinion doesn?t really matter, only the opinion of those that run the club. They are sticking with him and so MH and their decision to stick with him, will be judged after the last match on whether we survive or not. I still hope he proves all of us who doubt his abilities as a manager wrong, I will be very happy to say well done Matt if he keeps us up.

[millersrus]

Quite a disappointing result. Hoped before the game for point.
Whilst we were not quite at it, you have to give credit to Cardiff, they were excellent. Much the better side.
Hopefully this result does not define our season. We just need to keep our heads up, important games are against the teams around and just above us.
Keep the faith.
UTM

[Old_time_miller]

He played Douglas because he had to and then dropped him out of the match day squad when he was fit again to replace him with his new bloke.
Not saying he isn?t a good coach, I think there is evidence from his time with Warne that he has abilities in that role, but in my opinion he isn?t manager material. However my opinion like your opinion doesn?t really matter, only the opinion of those that run the club. They are sticking with him and so MH and their decision to stick with him, will be judged after the last match on whether we survive or not. I still hope he proves all of us who doubt his abilities as a manager wrong, I will be very happy to say well done Matt if he keeps us up.

I was replying to a question about proof of him being a good coach, that’s all. Which seems to be of younger players.
Those two players being a good example of him bringing them on. Whether he had to play Douglas is irrelevant. Douglas was often miles better than any defender in those games he played in. He was a bit dodgy in one game simply because he was having to do too much out of his comfort zone due to others.
Both Wiles and him are miles better than the shambles we are witnessing at times these day.

[avondalemiller]

Omari Kellyman who scored their 1st goal cost Chelsea 19 Million from Villa, and loaned him to Cardiff. To say were lost 0-3, and gave them 2 goals, we didn't do too bad..............lol

[CAMiller]

Omari Kellyman who scored their 1st goal cost Chelsea 19 Million from Villa, and loaned him to Cardiff. To say were lost 0-3, and gave them 2 goals, we didn't do too bad..............lol

That puts a bit of perspective on matters. On the flip side, rumour is we paid 1M+ for Sam and he managed to hit the corner flag with a header on Saturday

[Tigerish]

Yes and we got someone on loan from Villa. Lino Sousa.
But he was injured when we signed him.
You couldn't make it up

[Old_time_miller]

Yes and we got someone on loan from Villa. Lino Sousa.
But he was injured when we signed him.
You couldn't make it up

Why be surprised. It is not as if we do not do it regular. Look at watmore, he won’t be match fit either.