Summer Transfer Window 2020/21

Printable View

Show 10 post(s) from this thread on one page

31-07-2020, 10:41 AM
D31

I'm surprised it's a 19 yr old player weve brought in but i certainly wont be writing him off
31-07-2020, 10:49 AM
RedStarTorphins

Quote:

Originally Posted by Feck_the_Huns

So that’s this Edmondson guy written off already, yeah? Nae even fackin’ signed yet and the Depressive Dept have analysed it and decided?

If Motherwell signed him, we’d be jizzing all over how good he is

I give up sometimes.

Play up Dons (happy clap)

Just to stop you & AFC1803mad going all prom queen, and for clarity, I’m not dissing the lad at all.
All I said was talk of us signing an international striker has been brought in to some perspective & reality with the signing of someone who hasn’t played a first team game or scored a first team goal.
What’s wrong with that?
Stating a fact.
31-07-2020, 10:50 AM
BogBrush1903

Quote:

Originally Posted by Feck_the_Huns

So that’s this Edmondson guy written off already, yeah? Nae even fackin’ signed yet and the Depressive Dept have analysed it and decided?

If Motherwell signed him, we’d be jizzing all over how good he is

I give up sometimes.

Play up Dons (happy clap)

I don't think anybody is writing him off, rather more questioning the reasoning behind it. We all he hope he does well but what can we reasonably expect from a young loon with three senior league appearances and no goals coming to league he knows nothing about for six months.

We might as well give our own youngsters experience and see if we can improve them. If they aren't good enough then they shouldn't be here.
31-07-2020, 10:53 AM
DonUnder

Quote:

Originally Posted by afc1903mad

Cosgrove has a fair turn of pace on him and I was very impressed with Dykes pace when Livingston were last up at Pittodrie.
Probably the ideal is a player with "stature" who has a bot of pace about them.
That said, there have been many players of "stature" who were not blessed with pace but did quite well.

Ironically Cosgrove is quick but his 'big guy centre forward stuff' isn't so flash. Credit where it's due some of his finishes from 10-25 yards (Motherwell, St.Mirrren and St. Johnstone spring to mind) were non bigmanesque. Problem is they when he's there defenders are tempted to go long. I'd like to see us hit the chest of the guy in the middle Main is better at the back to goal stuff and so is McGinn.

Anyway Cosgrove is fckd hence the discussion.
31-07-2020, 10:53 AM
BogBrush1903

Quote:

Originally Posted by RedStarTorphins

Just to stop you & AFC1803mad going all prom queen, and for clarity, I’m not dissing the lad at all.
All I said was talk of us signing an international striker has been brought in to some perspective & reality with the signing of someone who hasn’t played a first team game or scored a first team goal.
What’s wrong with that?
Stating a fact.

I did question Main Stand Moan's motives and still do...
31-07-2020, 10:55 AM
BogBrush1903

Quote:

Originally Posted by DonUnder

Problem is they when he's there defenders are tempted to go long.

The old Duncan Ferguson for Scotland quandary. An easy out ball but very predictable...
31-07-2020, 11:04 AM
RedStarTorphins

Quote:

Originally Posted by BogBrush1903

I did question Main Stand Moan's motives and still do...

I’m not questioning MSM at all.
I’m just saying today’s news is a reality check & some perspective to where we are financially.
I’m not saying the guy Edmondson is pish or fantastic. We don’t know.
Hopefully AFC1903mad & feck the huns have spare underwear :O

Good luck to the lad assuming he signs.
I think he’ll start at McDiarmid if Bruce draws a blank against SEVCO tomorrow.
31-07-2020, 12:30 PM
BogBrush1903

Quote:

Originally Posted by RedStarTorphins

I’m not questioning MSM at all.

I think he’ll start at McDiarmid if Bruce draws a blank against SEVCO tomorrow.

You must be questioning MSM if they tell us an international striker is coming in and with heavy hints towards Fletcher (not Jordan Rhodes but...) and you're, rightly I think, reminding us of our weak current financial standing?

I really hope he doesn't drop Anderson if he doesn't have the impact he wants. He needs a run of games before judgements on his longer term suitability are cast.
31-07-2020, 12:48 PM
bucky1973

He has extended his contract at Leeds before coming here on loan
31-07-2020, 12:51 PM
RedStarTorphins

Quote:

Originally Posted by BogBrush1903

You must be questioning MSM if they tell us an international striker is coming in and with heavy hints towards Fletcher (not Jordan Rhodes but...) and you're, rightly I think, reminding us of our weak current financial standing?

I really hope he doesn't drop Anderson if he doesn't have the impact he wants. He needs a run of games before judgements on his longer term suitability are cast.

We possibly “asked the question” (c/o McInnes) of Fletcher & when he told us his wage requirements we moved on.
McInnes did say they’ve been looking for a striker since last Saturday.

As for Anderson, I just don’t think McInnes trusts him to lead the line.
He prefers a big strong no9, hence the potential
Edmondson signing.
I always get the feeling Bruce has to score to keep his place, which isn’t really fair.
But that’s what I think might happen.
If he gets no change out of SEVCO’s back 4, he’ll be subbed off after 65 & on will come Edmondson if he signs & will start the week after.
Just my opinion.

Show 10 post(s) from this thread on one page