Reply With QuoteThe rule of an automatic yellow card for removing your shirt when celebrating scoring a goal is one of the stupidest, most pointless rules in football.
To date I've never heard any valid reason for this rule/punishment.
Hall Of Fame
The situation won’t have to get much worse before something will have to be done.
eg
Scrapping the playoffs all together.
All matches behind closed doors.
Possibly just the finals at Wembley with fans where security is better with regard to pitch invasions.
Hall Of Fame
The rule of an automatic yellow card for removing your shirt when celebrating scoring a goal is one of the stupidest, most pointless rules in football.
To date I've never heard any valid reason for this rule/punishment.
Hall Of Fame
What's even more stupid is a player doing it in the full knowledge he will get a yellow card.Originally Posted by laddo
Hall Of Fame
Virtually anything that will be done will effect fans whether they are causing trouble or not.
Closing grounds, docking points, reducing attendance or anything else apart from fines for the club.
Someone suggested on the news this morning that the first couple of rows around the ground could be covered over thus making it difficult for fans to climb over.
Hall Of Fame
I don't know the official reason(s), I'd guess one could be that it wastes time if they've thrown it into the crowd or they've run half a pitch away after dropping it and everybody then has to wait until they have gone to fetch it and put it back on again.
If they've got slogans on t-shirts under the shirt, they're on display for longer (though I think there is a separate rule for that now)
Inciting the crowd? Which wouldn't make much sense but not all rules have to make a great deal of sense if the real reason is just that a few people running the game have decided it's not very British or we need to protect pubescent girls who might be tempted to do the same thing on the playground or some other silly reason.
Hall Of Fame
And that's the usual response you hear.
Stupid rule set in the first place followed by an even stupider action albeit in the heat of the moment of ecstasy.
This is no chicken and egg situation, scrap one of the most needless rules and punishment in football and problem solved. This isn't jumping into the crowd whilst celebrating its removing an item of clothing.
Hall Of Fame
I had been told it was because the shirt sponsors wanted to ensure that their logo is visible when the goal scorer is celebrating on televised games. No idea if it is true but money is king nowadays.
Hall Of Fame
Whether it's a stupid rule or not, it's a rule. Is it that difficult to celebrate a goal with your shirt on?
Unless of course you enjoy seeing players in those weird man-bras.
Hall Of Fame
I'm still trying to find someone who thinks it isn't a stupid needless rule.
The search continues....
Rules can be bad and can and should be changed.
I enjoy the proper goal celebrations of today, rather than a single leap into the air before a swift walk back to the centre circle to restart the game, politely shaking a few team mates hands along the way. Very British.
Hall Of Fame
Official York City twitter half an hour ago "YANNOUNCEMENT: Supporters are asked please do not enter the field of play at the final whsitle."
Official York City twitter just now "Our Moment" together with a video showing fans invading the pitch at the final whistle.
Posting Permissions