
Originally Posted by
bigroof
Wouldn't say knowledgeable, but Marco Crisp's book "Match By Match" shows the two clubs met in the various Cheshire cups a few times before the 1WW. It doesn't detail minor round games since then, so it's possible there have been other meetings, but I don't recall any myself since starting to follow Crewe from the early 80's. Pretty sure they've never met in the FA Cup, and their first teams have never played in the same league.
Marco's book points out an interesting tale of the County cup meetings in 1915: Crewe were the home team, and leading Nantwich 2-1 during extra time, when some Nantwich fans invaded the pitch. The referee abandoned the game. Nantwich won the re-arranged game.