Quote Originally Posted by tHeArAb View Post
Aye and look at the season we've had, absolutely horrendous. They're 1 point ahead of us mate. Like I said, he's proving right now that he's a better manager than McKinnon although McKinnon was doing equally as good as Hopkin was when he was with Raith. Does a dozen or so games mean he can handle going full time with the pressure of being Dundee Utd manager? I wouldn't want to take that chance.
makes no sense your argument - you have mentioned 4 or 5 contrasting situations that cant be measured. What is true is that how do we know he can handle this job. Just like every single applicant in my view. Isnt that a risk we have to take with any manager? I agree if we can get a manager full of experience then great. which manager full of experience without flaws are on the list though? Yogi, Mcintyre??

All relative. for one yeah i agree he prob isnt the one but jesus some on here will argue against any candidate