Quote Originally Posted by curvasud View Post
Completely insane and outright wrong.

I'll expand.

Calderwood 2 semi finals including the worst bottling ever and the other was bad too

61, 54, 65, 53, 53 points

McInnes 8 semi finals 4 finals 1 win

68, 75, 71, 76, 73, 67 points
A fair chunk of DMs reign has been in a weakened league and cups though.
No Rangers for a fair bit, Hearts, Hibs and D Utd either relegated or relatively weak for chunks of it.

Anything other than at least 2nd during his time is a failure, and that’s happened twice with Motherwell beating us into 3rd and Killie putting us 4th. Getting to the semis surely also must be/have been a bare minimum with the weakened cups?

For me, he’s done probably a bit less than bare minimum.