Bit early to be writing off the left back, though He didn’t do himself any favours yesterday, don’t forget how quick fans were to write off Edwards as no better than Connolly at the start. McMann is average, was part to blame for livi goal. Sheep definitely deserves a shot now at right back now, but he has become Cafu in his absence from the team, he is fairly slow and def not suited to left back.

Biggest worry for me besides keepers is that lack of defensive midfielder, McGrath and harkes bombing forward, levitt third centre half, nobody anchoring midfield and just holding the position. Huge gaps for opposition to exploit as seen at goals, and no one in team to win a tackle other than centre halves.

sibbald nearest we have to someone we have that wins ball and retains possession, he bought him and is not even playing him. Midfield was offering no protection, creating nothing and had no control. But it is midfield/forwards problem. Watt/fletcher both slow for closing down from top, fletcher isolated, watt too slow for wing.