Jim Goodwin

[ZakkTheMakk]

Glass got pumped 3-0 by Dundee United in the Scottish Cup and 4-0 by the Huns a few games later.

Let’s not try to rewrite history,Glass was just as bad as Goodwin is.Both terrible appointments by Cormack.

Lets get facts correct before spouting drivel shall we?? We got beat by Motherwell in the Scottish cup and lost 1-0 against Sevco a few games later (under Goodwin). If you're referring to the previous season then it's unfair to judge a manager on the previous managers players.

Goodwin harps on about it's his players yadda yadda but with his players we've had a fair few skelpings. It was never the case under Glass with is players and that is the point I was making

Looking back over the fixtures then I am correct when I say we never lost by more than 2 goals under Glass.

A little apology goes a long way

[Shetland Don]

I’d suggest that the fans boycott the Hibs game, and indeed all games, in protest, till JG is out. After all, this Club pulls the p*** out of fans and puts on displays that are not fit for purpose. I think that JG has fallen out with too many players and that there’s issues behind the scenes - is Shinnie maybe the latest!?

[mondo_notion]

Does Cormack think we will win at Easter Road on Saturday with Goodwin still in the dugout? Does Goodwin think we will win?

I can only imagine the delay is getting a deal signed off regarding the termination of his contract.

[ZakkTheMakk]

It wouldn't surprise me if we went to Easter Road and won and the players and management believed it was full redemption after so many games of sh*t.

But in reality I think with or without Goodwin there we'll get beat, by a couple of goals at least.

[pieandbovrilman]

Is a f*cking spud but he thinks he isn’t. Proper Jimmy Calderwood thick but more articulate

Bump

[rico94]

Lets get facts correct before spouting drivel shall we?? We got beat by Motherwell in the Scottish cup and lost 1-0 against Sevco a few games later (under Goodwin). If you're referring to the previous season then it's unfair to judge a manager on the previous managers players.

Goodwin harps on about it's his players yadda yadda but with his players we've had a fair few skelpings. It was never the case under Glass with is players and that is the point I was making

Looking back over the fixtures then I am correct when I say we never lost by more than 2 goals under Glass.

A little apology goes a long way

Is that right,well it didn’t seem to stop folk on here criticising Goodwin last season when he was in charge of the players Glass left him.

You said that Glass never lost by more than 2 goals when he clearly did,here’s another one for you too.Both of them have 42 games as manager for us and we conceded more goals under Glass than we have under Goodwin.


https://afcheritage.org/Team/Manager...?manager_id=46

[ZakkTheMakk]

Is that right,well it didn’t seem to stop folk on here criticising Goodwin last season when he was in charge of the players Glass left him.

You said that Glass never lost by more than 2 goals when he clearly did,here’s another one for you too.Both of them have 42 games as manager for us and we conceded more goals under Glass than we have under Goodwin.


https://afcheritage.org/Team/Manager...?manager_id=46

Folk can criticise as much as they want, Goodwin came in and right off the bat he alienated a large portion of the squad with his assessment of them. The players that were told they were no good downed tools and the end to that season was a horror show. Things could've been handled a lot better but Goodwins style of management didn't allow for that.

Onto this season and once again there are reports of players having run-ins with Jim, this is to the detriment of the squad and possibly the results also.

Under Goodwin we have played 7 games against lower league opposition and Glass played 2 and also 6 games against European teams, one would imagine we should be conceding less goals if that is the case. Lets take out the 6 European and 2 lower league games for Glass and the 7 lower league games for Goodwin and see where we stand? That would just leave their league and cup against premier teams record which is a fairer way to judge?

Glass's team (including McInnes players) conceded 46 if we count cup games against premier teams and Goodwins team (including Glass's) conceding 52 if my figures are correct.

That would have Glass's team conceding 6 goals less than Goodwins over a comparable number of games, less skelpings, no worst result in our history, better on the eye all for less money spent on squad.

I have to make it clear that I'm not a Glass fanboy, just merely pointing out their respective records as our manager and Goodwin falls short by a long way compared to Glass

[stewarty27]

[QUOTE=Shetland Don;40200296 I think that JG has fallen out with too many players and that there’s issues behind the scenes - is Shinnie maybe the latest!?[/QUOTE]

Christian Ramirez is a good example of Goodwin's man management. CR was a natural goal scorer a great first season. Then along comes Goodwin and CR is treated like a lump o sh1te and a real penalty box player is dumped. Why ?

[TheDeeDon]

Can we not just agree the appointments of both Glass and Goodwin were Shyte and move on?

Seems a petty argument.

[ZakkTheMakk]

Glass's appointment was good in theory, someone from outside the norm etc etc but it ultimately didn't work out and his time was up before he eventually got the bullet. Goodwins was just a panic appointment plain and simple, Cormack shat his knacks after binning Glass and the whole structure on why he hired Glass in the first place was thrown out the window.