Kelly

[gru]

It's all immaterial. Until GK moves on there is no bet to be had. He could end up spending another 5 years at RUFC yet. So far on GPG he's about level with JCH on production at RUFC and 3x more prolific than JY.

JCH while we've been at the NYS tell me a better signing in his position? I can't think of one. Smith wasn't.

[CAMiller]

JCH while we've been at the NYS tell me a better signing in his position? I can't think of one. Smith wasn't.

It might be a long list if you are going on GPG.

MS 1 every 3.5
Matt Derbyshire 1 every 4
.
.
.
Jordan Bowery 1 every 8
JCH 1 every 9

I'll admit he was better than Dexter Blackstock at 1 every 16

[howdydoo]

JCH while we've been at the NYS tell me a better signing in his position? I can't think of one. Smith wasn't.

Revell
Ward
Moore

JCH showed some potential but his onfield attitude wasn't right.

If Evans was getting the best out of him, i'd hate to have seen him during a bad spell.

He was awful for us.


To compare him to Smith is silly.


Over a 10 game spell JCH might rate 9 out of 10 in 1 game. The other 9 games it would be 4's, 5's and 6's.


Smith would be solid 6's, 7's and 8's and he scored more goals for us.