
Originally Posted by
neilthedon
Y'know I doubt many sides have the players effective enough to play,dominate and win games playing a back five .
Mainly because you need superstar athletic wingbacks..? Like Andy Robertson . And how many are there ?
We've tried converting wingers, but they seem to lack the defensive skills.
We've tried pushing fullbacks forward. And they are never the best crossers on the attack .
Also when the backs are pushing forward you need a good mobile set of Centrehalfs to cover the spaces. And know who will cover what.
Looked like we struck lucky last season with Scales, Pollock & McDonald. That wasn't long thought out. They were thrown together.
So the back four is far steadier. Easier for them to know their positions to defend. Plus it gives us an extra midfielder or Forward.
Last night the abilities of Barron were obvious. Prior to this Shiñie was being pulled all over. And it showed.
A better defensive midfield allows the forwards room further up the park to press defensively and to attack. No surprise Clarkson got to show his cheeky stuff. McGrath too. ( Boy does the ball stick to his feet !!). Note Miovski didn't have to run way back to get the ball either ?
Nice to also see Ryan Duncan get to come on and play his best position , forward wide attacking. Sokler always looks useful these days.
This , with hindsight ( yes, many were saying it ages ago). is the best starting formation. With decent attacking options to come on from the bench.
Fine tuning still needed. Polvaro was put out as the wide-ish right sided attacker. New to him. He may well adapt. ?
We , err BR & Cormack should treat resigning Barron like they would view signing thon boy Technic. A top priority . Value him as a million pound signing , promise him future Captain's role and pay him a good wedge. The position he plays is important, nay crucial to this team. Get it done AFC. FMB. !!!