Those released. Where will they land?

[queenslandpie]

I agree I’d be shocked if he went down a level and not totally surprised if he went up one.

Really?

I would be more than surprised if he went up one. Can't see him in L2. Not with last season on his resume despite what was expected of him.

[matt_magpie]

Really?

I would be more than surprised if he went up one. Can't see him in L2. Not with last season on his resume despite what was expected of him.

Everyone keeps saying his clangers but out of nearly 90 goals we let in how many were down to his clangers? The game that really stuck out was Shrewsbury but that was the FA cup. It’s worrying if he’s not good enough for L2 as for me he was our best defender last season, it will be interesting to see where he ends up.

[nw6pie]

Everyone keeps saying his clangers but out of nearly 90 goals we let in how many were down to his clangers? The game that really stuck out was Shrewsbury but that was the FA cup. It’s worrying if he’s not good enough for L2 as for me he was our best defender last season, it will be interesting to see where he ends up.

He was good for a stupid mistake in way too many games, it wasn’t just the goals he gave away. One that stands out for me was at Mansfield, where he gifted them the ball playing out from the back. He then did well to win the ball back, only to give it away straight after and gift them a chance.

If he can cut out the errors and those frequent lapses in concentration, he’ll be a quality lower-league player. We just didn’t see any proof that he could do that this season.

[queenslandpie]

Everyone keeps saying his clangers but out of nearly 90 goals we let in how many were down to his clangers? The game that really stuck out was Shrewsbury but that was the FA cup. It’s worrying if he’s not good enough for L2 as for me he was our best defender last season, it will be interesting to see where he ends up.

I said "with last season on his resume". He will probably be ok in a "normal" back 4. It's fair to see given the number of goals we conceded that most of the defence was not good enough last season and I would put Macari above him as the best defender - by some way. I cannot count the number of clangers without going through that video somebody posted of all the goals but it will be a considerable number I would say between 7 and 10. Far far too many. The odd one well it happens but he would make a glaring stupid error in pretty much every game he played that gifted the opposition a good chance. they did not always convert into goals.

[Lullapie]

I said "with last season on his resume". He will probably be ok in a "normal" back 4. It's fair to see given the number of goals we conceded that most of the defence was not good enough last season and I would put Macari above him as the best defender - by some way. I cannot count the number of clangers without going through that video somebody posted of all the goals but it will be a considerable number I would say between 7 and 10. Far far too many. The odd one well it happens but he would make a glaring stupid error in pretty much every game he played that gifted the opposition a good chance. they did not always convert into goals.

He will be a good player in any team that doesn't fanny about with the ball at the back and may be able to be the type of defender he was in the play-off semi last season - a bit like Mark Ellis was for Notts. It was unfair expecting him to play the role that was asked of him in League 2, as it was obvious that all of the Notts defence struggled to play that way in the National League. The only difference was that the attacking abilities of the teams in the National League wasn't as good as it was in League 2.

[queenslandpie]

He will be a good player in any team that doesn't fanny about with the ball at the back and may be able to be the type of defender he was in the play-off semi last season - a bit like Mark Ellis was for Notts. It was unfair expecting him to play the role that was asked of him in League 2, as it was obvious that all of the Notts defence struggled to play that way in the National League. The only difference was that the attacking abilities of the teams in the National League wasn't as good as it was in League 2.

Never really broke into MK Dons team much before Notts but I think they were League One then. Anyway best of luck to him.

[matt_magpie]

I said "with last season on his resume". He will probably be ok in a "normal" back 4. It's fair to see given the number of goals we conceded that most of the defence was not good enough last season and I would put Macari above him as the best defender - by some way. I cannot count the number of clangers without going through that video somebody posted of all the goals but it will be a considerable number I would say between 7 and 10. Far far too many. The odd one well it happens but he would make a glaring stupid error in pretty much every game he played that gifted the opposition a good chance. they did not always convert into goals.

Fair comment, I admit he’s made a lot of mistakes but the guy was probably passing the ball more than anyone else on the pitch and sat as the last man of the team. If the other 2 hit a rubbish pass down the flanks and it’s cut out or they dribble it down there and lose it, it’s not as half as catastrophic.
Trying to ignore some of the clangers and silly bookings I wish him well, 2 great goals in the semis and part of the winning final team, any of those players get my backing.