Board statement on transfer business

[northpie1862]

Nothing can be done now though can it so what more can you do? 😂 Does Brown excite you in the formation we play? Does having two youth players in centre midfield excite you? How about I put it this way, use the money we've spent on Hinchy and the chap from Tottenham as well as some of the "substantial" money from LW, ML and AN departures and go and get Charlie McCann. Young but proven, instead we go for options that just don't excite and feel more like Tipton than tip top

So after all your bedwetting about players you havent even seen kick a ball yet the only suggestion you can come up with is…

Charlie McCann, a player now plying his trade in the NL who was an ever present in one of the worst Forest Green sides of the last decade, thats your suggestion?

The more you speak the more I realise why no one listens to you, don’t apply for a job at Football Radar any time soon.

[MAD_MAGPIE]

Last season we had a league one attack and a national league defence. We scored a huge number of goals but also conceded a huge number of goals. Those were the basic facts and stats. We were also in a post Luke Williams slump and hangover in the second half of the season. A baptism of fire also for Stuart Maynard making the step up from part time to full time and the club seemingly being in an after the Lord Mayors show mood.

The club have been bold in that they have looked to address these by releasing a number of players who were out of contract but also under contract and part of the Luke Williams era. This was particularly in defence which has enabled Stuart Maynard to have his own team and give him the best opportunity to make the step up and be higher.

The other big thing is that we have held onto the family silver in our best key players notably Jodi Jones and Dan Cowley. Obviously Macca has gone to Milwall and if the money for Macca has meant we have not needed to sell Crowley or Jones this summer and that they could see out their contracts like Wootton and Rodrigues previously then with Jatta being brought for £150k earlier in the year I’m happy with this business.

In my opinion the club now have a year to prepare for what I believe to be the ultimate departure of Jones and Crowley regardless if we get promoted or not as I foresee them following the path of Rodrigues moving up two levels. January will be an opportunity to bring in potential replacements like Jatta for Macca last January, unless they are already in the building but under the radar and will shine over the season.

I like that the club have brought in some young players as well with potential both our own players and loans so thinking ahead.

The squad seems to be more balanced this season on the face of it and time will tell. I do think overall it is a stronger squad and am confident in time this will be proven by finishing higher than last seasons 14th place. ItÂ’s a tiny sample but our results so far have been better than the equivalent games last season and we have had two draws against a former league one and current league one team.

The cherry on the cake would be a win at Swindon today to exercise the ghost of relegation that hangs over the county ground and the magic roundabout down there.

[Wedgie_pie]

Does it all start again in January 25 ?
Will we hang on to Jones and Crowley ?
Will the woman slapping, alcohol loving, "everybody deserves a second chance" still be with us ?

Can't wait for next January episode to begin...

[LeftPeg_Pie]

Nothing can be done now though can it so what more can you do? 😂 Does Brown excite you in the formation we play? Does having two youth players in centre midfield excite you? How about I put it this way, use the money we've spent on Hinchy and the chap from Tottenham as well as some of the "substantial" money from LW, ML and AN departures and go and get Charlie McCann. Young but proven, instead we go for options that just don't excite and feel more like Tipton than tip top

I just find it baffling that on some issues you’ve been so sure they’re a bad thing. But now it’s time to wait.

Brown’s clearly an adaptable player and whether we play 3 or 4 at the back, I can see where he would fit. Lots of players are adaptable, which is a positive.

I’d be amazed if Hinchy and Abbott both started alongside each other too often. From what I’ve seen, I like Hinchy. Looks good on the ball, nice passing range and hasn’t been scared to get stuck in. I also think coming into a game after 25 minutes and picking up the pace quickly is a great sign early doors.

I understand the frustration of not splashing the cash. Lots of fans want that money turned around ASAP. But I can also understand why you may hold off, especially at our level. Spending big sums at our level is much riskier than higher up the pyramid because money can be hard to come by and the impact of that player doesn’t perform and in turn the team can be a big burden.

Your final line sums it up… “feel more like Tipton” why are you making this assumption? What’s led you there?

If you’ve watched tons of Abbott and Hinchy in the PL2 and have loads of reference points for them, then I apologise. But I struggle to reconcile when on one hand, it’s time to wait and see how we get on, but you’ve essentially written off two players part of the squad.

[Chicken Balti Pie]

So after all your bedwetting about players you havent even seen kick a ball yet the only suggestion you can come up with is…

Charlie McCann, a player now plying his trade in the NL who was an ever present in one of the worst Forest Green sides of the last decade, thats your suggestion?

The more you speak the more I realise why no one listens to you, don’t apply for a job at Football Radar any time soon.

Sorry to disappoint you but we had bids rejected for him so the board obviously wanted him also, just didn't push the boat out

[Chicken Balti Pie]

I just find it baffling that on some issues you’ve been so sure they’re a bad thing. But now it’s time to wait.

Brown’s clearly an adaptable player and whether we play 3 or 4 at the back, I can see where he would fit. Lots of players are adaptable, which is a positive.

I’d be amazed if Hinchy and Abbott both started alongside each other too often. From what I’ve seen, I like Hinchy. Looks good on the ball, nice passing range and hasn’t been scared to get stuck in. I also think coming into a game after 25 minutes and picking up the pace quickly is a great sign early doors.

I understand the frustration of not splashing the cash. Lots of fans want that money turned around ASAP. But I can also understand why you may hold off, especially at our level. Spending big sums at our level is much riskier than higher up the pyramid because money can be hard to come by and the impact of that player doesn’t perform and in turn the team can be a big burden.

Your final line sums it up… “feel more like Tipton” why are you making this assumption? What’s led you there?

If you’ve watched tons of Abbott and Hinchy in the PL2 and have loads of reference points for them, then I apologise. But I struggle to reconcile when on one hand, it’s time to wait and see how we get on, but you’ve essentially written off two players part of the squad.

What can now be done? transfer window is shut so all we can do is hope that it works out and we used up our bad luck with injuries last year.

I watch quite a bit of PL2 and academy football. There is a reason why the under 23 sides in the tin pot trophy never progress to the final stages, because when teams put out their full strength sides, they're just too good for them. They lack physicality and the energy needed in competitive adult football. Sure, they're very technically sound, but they don't have the other attributes yet to compete against seasoned pros. Now sure, there is the argument how do they get this without playing but do we need two in a position that is quite important to have physical attributes?

[PedroTheFisherman66]

And we let go two attackers who got a lot of those goals... And before you mention Jatta, he was already here last year so he contributed last year also

What are you on about.? I've not got a clue but whatever it is you have proved my point.We were an attacking side that scored bucket loads of goals that created a demand for our striker to the value of £ 750 k allegedly ! Shall we all pretend jatta doesnt exist and doesn't count for anything this season to fit your theory.
Morias left and scored nominal goals last season how many was it one.?.maybe 2.? We still have Crowley and Jones so even if we pretend Jattas goals dont count we still have threats in them along with Scott and Mcgoldrick.

[Boomerangpie]

Sorry to disappoint you but we had bids rejected for him so the board obviously wanted him also, just didn't push the boat out

So you wanted Notts to try and sign Charlie McCann and Notts did try to sign Charlie McCann by making multiple formal bids. Surely you cant complain at that.

If we made a bid but McCann’s club valued him higher and wanted to retain his services that sounds very similar to the Crowley situation. MK didn’t push the boat out.

I hope you are as passionate at the County Ground today as you are about Notts squad depth.

[Notts78]

What can now be done? transfer window is shut so all we can do is hope that it works out and we used up our bad luck with injuries last year.

I watch quite a bit of PL2 and academy football. There is a reason why the under 23 sides in the tin pot trophy never progress to the final stages, because when teams put out their full strength sides, they're just too good for them. They lack physicality and the energy needed in competitive adult football. Sure, they're very technically sound, but they don't have the other attributes yet to compete against seasoned pros. Now sure, there is the argument how do they get this without playing but do we need two in a position that is quite important to have physical attributes?

Sorry, this is drivel. Lads at 19/20/21/22 don’t lack physicality or energy. Sure some will, but so will some 30 somethings.
What academy sides lack compared to established squads is an array of experience, leadership, tactical and footballing nouse.
You sound like Alan Hansen who dismissed Man Itd as title challengers when Beckham and Co. came in to senior football as ****agers.

[LeftPeg_Pie]

What can now be done? transfer window is shut so all we can do is hope that it works out and we used up our bad luck with injuries last year.

I watch quite a bit of PL2 and academy football. There is a reason why the under 23 sides in the tin pot trophy never progress to the final stages, because when teams put out their full strength sides, they're just too good for them. They lack physicality and the energy needed in competitive adult football. Sure, they're very technically sound, but they don't have the other attributes yet to compete against seasoned pros. Now sure, there is the argument how do they get this without playing but do we need two in a position that is quite important to have physical attributes?

Like I say, I’d be amazed if Hinchy and Abbott play together too often, especially in the weeks coming up. But we’ve also got Palmer, Robertson, Edwards and Crowley who play CM. You’ve also asserted that Grant can play there too. It’s about squad building and having different attributes.

I agree that the young sides in the JPT are generally crap. But, we’re taking a single player in Abbott and putting him into a well functioning squad and team. He won’t be surrounded by those of a similar profile to himself. So the generalisation is fine, but why can’t we just wait, like you want to, and see how the individual gets on and develops?

The Charlie McCann thing is interesting too. If we’ve made bids for him and they’ve been knocked back and we’ve walked away, do you see that as a lack of ambition or sensible financial management? I appreciate its hard to know fully without knowing what bids we made. Similar to Crowley, are you happy that we’ve stuck to our guns and kept one of our best players? The two scenarios seem similar, again, without knowing the fine details. It’d be interesting to get your perspective on that.

As an aside to that, all the players we have brought in were wanted by the board, obviously. So why is McCann so different to others you’ve panned?