Another Collum phone call

[Returnofrros]

No ****ing way this should remain private.

This should be in public domain.

[BCram]

Sorry, too cryptic a comment for me. Has the club received an apology for Sylla's second yellow?

[Returnofrros]

Sorry, too cryptic a comment for me. Has the club received an apology for Sylla's second yellow?

No idea, docherty has spoken to Collum, dosent say if Collum thinks it's an error as conversation won't be disclosed.

Why not?

Where's the transparency from Dundee and Collum?

[islaydarkblue]

Sorry, too cryptic a comment for me. Has the club received an apology for Sylla's second yellow?

Even if they have it is too late as thanks to Greg Irvine and the referees in the VAR studio being asleep or biased in favour of Kilmarnock we have lost three points.

[Dodbroon]

Even if they have it is too late as thanks to Greg Irvine and the referees in the VAR studio being asleep or biased in favour of Kilmarnock we have lost three points.

Under the current rules VAR could not get involved due to it being a double yellow card sending off. If Irvine had given a straight red, often the norm for an 'elbowing' offence, then it could have been reviewed and overturned. I wonder if Irvine only gave the second yellow to in effect dismiss the player with no VAR consequences.

[Returnofrros]

Under the current rules VAR could not get involved due to it being a double yellow card sending off. If Irvine had given a straight red, often the norm for an 'elbowing' offence, then it could have been reviewed and overturned. I wonder if Irvine only gave the second yellow to in effect dismiss the player with no VAR consequences.

Officially yes but we all know refs get telt things if they are away to make an arse of it

Linesman on Derry side very close, 4th official surely in contact with var.....he never gave himself time to think or didn't want to think.

DFC shud be kicking off far more than they are .....easy touch on the pitch and off the pitch?

[parcbara]

[QUOTE=Returnofrros;40582940]Officially yes but we all know refs get telt things if they are away to make an arse of it

Linesman on Derry side very close, 4th official surely in contact with var.....he never gave himself time to think or didn't want to think.

DFC shud be kicking off far more than they are .....easy touch on the pitch and off the pitch?[/QUOTE

We are indeed, both on and off, especially on.

[Deeranged]

Officially yes but we all know refs get telt things if they are away to make an arse of it

Linesman on Derry side very close, 4th official surely in contact with var.....he never gave himself time to think or didn't want to think.

DFC shud be kicking off far more than they are .....easy touch on the pitch and off the pitch?

If they criticise or even question it publicly they'll get hammered by the muppets at the top.

[Returnofrros]

If they criticise or even question it publicly they'll get hammered by the muppets at the top.

Remember coming back from holiday and it was a Sunday I think and dabs had just lost at Ibrox and there was a cple of really controversial decisions against the dabs.

Avril in post match interview was going Tonto and used the phrase two or three times "ach but you won't report that it's only Dundee united, officials don't care it's only Dundee united".......I was jealous and mind thinking at the time although it was funny cause it was them well done for speaking out.....Im pretty sure he was censored but there didn't appear to be many dodgy decisions against them after it.

I'm being critical of Dundee and doc here because I believe conversation shud be made public and if Dundee/doc are happy with convo.

Have they been "promised" he won't officiate us again or the other end of scale, sit Doon, shut up it was a yellow.

I think more openness from DFC the better but again we are treated like mushrooms

[Returnofrros]

Tellingly for me Doc said "I haven't changed my mind".....which suggests to me Collum was justifying yellow.