Like you are bot a Trump supoorter I am not a die hard anti Trumper. By that I mean I think he is an awful person to have in a position of power but his chaos theory management of situations and willingness to say things against the grain can be and have been useful. I also agree that governments often use leverage over each other. What we often call diplomacy, which sounds like a nice friendly chat, is often a euphemism for an exchange of threats and favours.
I think what separates the Trump administration from others is the theatre of it all. He runs his government like a reality TV show. Can you remember North Korea missile testing a few years ago? One minute he was threatening to bomb them back to the stone age, the next he was doing a summit in front of the world's cameras and saving the world. IMO the exact same result would normally have been achieved, but away from public view.
The concessions he has gained from his tariffs (which were announced then postponed then reannounced on a Friday for a Tuesday, probably to give his ITK friends time to short the S&P 500 before it was all walked back) are very limited. Trump 1.0 obtained a Mexico troop deployment, as did Biden in 2021 (without the theatre). For his part Trump ceded a promise to stop the flow of weapons from the US to Mexico. The bulk of what Canada 'conceded' was already announced under Biden in December 2024.
Nothing that any of the three countries have conceded or gained is particularly unusual or significant, as far as I can tell. The reason for doing it like this could be to keep the Trump show in the news because that's the way he likes it, or just to throw some red meat to the Lullapies of the world who want to see the strong man WINNING!, or for some other reason we don't know yet.
Mexico troops deployments under Biden:
https://www.reuters.com/world/americ...al-2021-04-12/
Canada border security and Fentanyl disruption initiatives from Dec 2024:
https://www.canada.ca/en/public-safe...on-system.html