Jim Goodwin.

[TerryTheTerror]

It's hard to get a reaction from the players when individual errors are kicking the guts out of the other players . You start the game with a positive mindset then our young loanee thinks he's Baresi....0-1....then you try to get back into the game and our Finnish International (lol) royally fks up a 5 yard pass...0-2....I was gone after 70 minutes so don't know how the 3rd goal went but it must be absolutely galling for those players to react after those instances.

I honestly don't think it's a lack of a reaction or even effort. The players and especially the goalkeeper are just not good enough.

Yeah, that's a great summary for me. The third goal we just got caught in the break, was always likely to happen given the circumstances.

I thought it interesting JG made a point of talking with Newman at the end of the game. In my view he played pretty well and wasn't fault for any of the goals. Bet he was wishing he put him in earlier in his tenure now. 🤔

[LSArab]

Sorry but the manager can't be absolved of any responsibility just because folk like the cut of his jib, otherwise Fox and Ross should be afforded the same courtesy. Yes the players are a ****ing disgrace to the shirt, but he's got absolutely no reaction from them at all so I fail to see how he's the answer. He can go with the rest of the shyte for me.

I don’t absolve JG of any responsibility. I’m disappointed he couldn’t get more out of the players.

However the problem lies within the set of players.

3 managers now have tried to get a tune out of them and they are completely gutless

JG not perfect but he is the best that is available

Let him mould a hungry team in his image and let’s see where it takes us next season

[Arabknight]

If it is not depressing enough people wanting to bring in Robbie Neilson leaving aside the fact he walked out on United for Hearts, his football was sterile and only achieved promotion because the board brought in Shankland to bang in the goals and his first choice centre half Mark Connolly got injured and we stopped leaking goals. I will never forget the fist pump at the end of extra time in the play off with 10 man St Mirren showing no ambition to win the game then the worst set of penalty kicks we have ever seen.

Not to mention his call for us to stay down and hearts to remain in the premiership.

[the_arab]

im split on it, i wasnt bothered when he left because Shankland did pretty much get us promoted single handidly. Playing 2 defensive mids at home against teams at the bottom of the championship was unbearable at times BUT you cant take away from the fact he has went in to basket cases, turned them round and got them promoted and thats what we need

If we get either Goodwin or Neilson im okay with it

[swanny14]

im split on it, i wasnt bothered when he left because Shankland did pretty much get us promoted single handidly. Playing 2 defensive mids at home against teams at the bottom of the championship was unbearable at times BUT you cant take away from the fact he has went in to basket cases, turned them round and got them promoted and thats what we need

If we get either Goodwin or Neilson im okay with it

Imagine having TWO defensive midfielders available to pick🤣🤣🤣!!!

[Arabdownsouth]

**** Neilson

[arab777]

**** Neilson

If only there was a like button

[Mecca_Sheikh]

If it is not depressing enough people wanting to bring in Robbie Neilson leaving aside the fact he walked out on United for Hearts, his football was sterile and only achieved promotion because the board brought in Shankland to bang in the goals and his first choice centre half Mark Connolly got injured and we stopped leaking goals. I will never forget the fist pump at the end of extra time in the play off with 10 man St Mirren showing no ambition to win the game then the worst set of penalty kicks we have ever seen.

This. No to Neilson.

I can't see Ogren funding our escape.

[scobiemacd]

Aberdeen fan. Genuinely saddened to see Utd go down. Tannadice away is always a good visit not to mention the Dundee derby games which are always a great watch.

Was astonished that Goodwin was brought in to your club.To me there’s just something about the bloke where the players won’t play for him after a few months of his ‘man management’. I’m also of the belief he would have got Aberdeen relegated had we not sacked him( a few weeks too late when it did eventually happen).
Hope you lads bounce back soon👍

[arab777]

Aberdeen fan. Genuinely saddened to see Utd go down. Tannadice away is always a good visit not to mention the Dundee derby games which are always a great watch.

Was astonished that Goodwin was brought in to your club.To me there’s just something about the bloke where the players won’t play for him after a few months of his ‘man management’. I’m also of the belief he would have got Aberdeen relegated had we not sacked him( a few weeks too late when it did eventually happen).
Hope you lads bounce back soon👍

Jury still out on Goodwin. He did well at Alloa and St Mirren and at your club up until The World Cup break (he had you 3rd going in to the break). It was after that things took a tumble. For what its worth I've said before Barry Robson had the right ingredients for going in to management and as a former player thought United should have gone for him last year when we knew he was learning the coaching side of the game at Aberdeen. Not surprised how he is doing at Aberdeen.