|
| + Visit Dundee United FC Mad for Latest News, Transfer Gossip, Fixtures and Match Results |
Ganging up or voicing a different opinion?
Three people who have a different opinion on the Harkes/Butcher debate you mean? That's all it is, a different opinion. You're allowed that on a football forum.
Chick was shot down? I assume this is aimed at me? He in fact started the debate when I suggested we're disadvantaged this season without Shankland. I gave my opinion back, and quite rightly so, he did likewise. We didn't 'shoot each other down' we debated our opinions, disagreed and got on with it.
The board is very open. Everyone has a different opinion. This is what keeps the place going & makes it work imo. No one owns the board whatsoever.
As you've been reading the forum most days while you've been away, I'm sure you'll have noticed Craigbrew has a somewhat aggressive posting style and regularly attacks Shedkas views and opinions, along with recently calling ADS an idiot and a ****. I'm surprised you haven't mentioned this in your damming report of Utd Mad when you talk of guys ganging up, dissenting voices and folk being shot down.
Last edited by tHeArAb; 11-05-2022 at 07:19 AM.
Yep, I've not really seen anyone who's said they are happy with the style of play. But refusal to give credit to the management for potentially finishing 4th with an unbalanced squad and virtually no fire power is just churlish in my opinion. Comments like the 'head in the sand brigade' make me laugh tbh when it's coming in the same breath as ganging up on people for voicing their opinion.
Interesting - chicken and egg. I tend to agree (and have prasiedbeing 4th!!) - deep down i want Courts and Tony out BUT maybe the issue is all Tony's or maybe its we have too many cooks in background, maybe courts doesnt pick team. The key issue is the unbalanced squad, no creativity, lightweight kids being thrown in not ready, obvious ommissions that should start (freeman), weird subs and lastly no striker and lastly againresigning players who were p!sh first time round even as loan players. So whoever is responsible for all of that or the majority of that needs to change or leave. 4th is epic really in circumstances but with the same p!shing in the wind as last two seasons we could be in trouble next season.
So i agree with everyone (except for the bits i dont agree with)
Its just so fvcking frustrating, things like ibrox were embarrasing. I suppose some folk get more annoyed at the odd poster tryng to defend the indefensible. Each to their own and it could be argued those posters are just more glass half full folk and positive. I look at the table and think fvck sake thats amazing, i got to a game and think fvck sake i never want to go back. Of course we all end up going back.
So really stoke has his opinion, the positive posters too (i wish i had that positivity), some banter and some aggressive stuff. i like the board even though i scratch my head at some of the comments. then again i probably contribute to most of the scratching of heads when i post angry/p!ssed/nuts
Something just not right with our recruitment, squad, selctions etc and thats always going to get negative comments (from me included) when performances are as woeful as they have been.