WHO is better ? KEOGH or SHACKELL ??

[KingCharlieGeorge]

Shackell by quite a margin. I'm not convinced Keogh is good enough for the Premier.

[Anywho]

The sum of the parts is less than the whole. They compilment each other well.

That’s synergy for you.

[AdiSalisbury]

They play different positions, so not really fair to compare. However, if I had to lose one, I'd rather loose Shackell than Keogh.

[helloloves]

I would have said Shackell by a mile a year ago.....now...I'm not so sure.

Its a tough call.............as i'm no Keogh fan.......

BUT Shackell is past his best....and Keogh keeps on keeping on.

I'm sitting on the fence.

EVEN STEVEN.

Shackell is a better defender, reads the game better.
Keogh is better with the ball but needs a Shackell beside him. Never been a Keogh fan, big heart, yes..
I guess they kinda worked as a partnership last season.
Get off the fence, thought you were a Londoner? shacks wins it.
[/quote]

Ok - I'll reluctantly go for Shackell.............Keogh without his mistakes I'd prefer.

[lancyclaret]

Has Shackell been worth the £3 million you paid us last summer? I am a bit disappointed the Rams did not get promotion as Burnley would havel received "nice little add-ons" rising to £500,000 for Shacks if Derby had made the Premier League next season and managed to avoid relegation....an extra £250,000 for going up and £250,000 for staying up.

We have a similar agreement with Brentford for Gray.....£6 million up front with an extra £3 million dependent on promotion (achieved), goals scored (achieved), appearances (achieved), PL survival (hopefully) and England caps (possible I suppose).

[helloloves]

[quote="lancyclaret" rising to £500,000 for Shacks if Derby had made the Premier League next season and managed to avoid relegation....an extra £250,000 for going up and £250,000 for staying up.

We have a similar agreement with Brentford for Gray.....£6 million up front with an extra £3 million dependent on promotion (achieved), goals scored (achieved), appearances (achieved), PL survival (hopefully) and England caps (possible I suppose).[/quote]


NO - not worth it - he was brilliant first time around - seems a bit robotic to me nowadays.