Clements and Sky

[triz]

I can.....warnock played well on Saturday, certainly better than christie did against burnley who wasted everything that came to him. People bummed christie and slated warnock, some clueless people gave him 3/10!! What a joke. Minds are made up on him and he's too old and not the future.

[AnagRam]

Take your word for it Triz. Didn't see Saturday, don't believe he's too old and hope he comes good, but have to admit I've been disappointed so far.

[Bear DCFC]

The decision that confused me was the keeper, Carson dropped for one game when he made no mistakes, only to be restored a game later. The Warnock/Forsyth rotation is less surprising to me, we see it in the Prem so why not the Championship? Most agree that Warnock had his best game in a Derby shirt. I'd be more concerned if he was swapping CBs every game. It tells me that he's a thoughtful coach who knows how to pick a team to win - recent results confirm that.

Rapid - you posted a couple weeks ago that you've seen enough of Clement's Derby to know that he isn;t going to get us promoted. I was surprised to read that post from you as you're normally a lot more rational. I think this is the kind of comment which is unhelpful and in hindsight perhaps you regret? I don't know, maybe you don't. I just think we owe it to everyone concerned to give him time, some read these types of comments and carry them onto Twitter, which the coach/players read. I think as supporters we have re

[AngryRam]

I can.....warnock played well on Saturday, certainly better than christie did against burnley who wasted everything that came to him. People bummed christie and slated warnock, some clueless people gave him 3/10!! What a joke. Minds are made up on him and he's too old and not the future.

I gave him 3/10 because that's how I saw his performance ... I cant justify giving him another 3 marks just because he made a decent cross to Johnson..
So we dont agree.. Well there is a surprise.. Clueless? Feck off.

[soluhullram]

I can.....warnock played well on Saturday, certainly better than christie did against burnley who wasted everything that came to him. People bummed christie and slated warnock, some clueless people gave him 3/10!! What a joke. Minds are made up on him and he's too old and not the future.

I think the words pot and kettle come to mind here. No matter what Christie does or doesn't do some people continually slate him. Was it Christie who got easily turned at a corner against MK only for the forward to blaze over the bar, or was Christie who made an almighty mess of a simple back pass that again should have resulted in a tap in. Because he is not causing goals to be conceded, he is getting the blame for not picking out one striker in the middle of 5 or 6 defenders. I'm just waiting for Keogh to make a mistake which results in a goal conceded, then the floodgates will open.

[FindernRam]

I don't know where you feel I had a go at PC. I'm happy to giver the guy a fair crack at the job. However I don't agree that means I have to stay silent when things are patently not right in the team, be it tactics, fitness or player motivation, whatever! This board is about debate!!!!
If he sorts it out great. If he doesn't then he is not the man for the job, but I won't be calling for his head until well into next year-by which time promotion will be a dream for another year.

[Bear DCFC]

I can.....warnock played well on Saturday, certainly better than christie did against burnley who wasted everything that came to him. People bummed christie and slated warnock, some clueless people gave him 3/10!! What a joke. Minds are made up on him and he's too old and not the future.

I gave him 3/10 because that's how I saw his performance ... I cant justify giving him another 3 marks just because he made a decent cross to Johnson..
So we dont agree.. Well there is a surprise.. Clueless? Feck off.
[/quote]

Sometimes Angry, just sometimes, I think you're a forest fan in disguise.

[ellafella]

We have a PC hate mob growing quite nicely on this board.

Luckless
Findern Ram
B Stand
Ramspride
Paulo570
Rapid
Angry
Vanderlaans_header
chilli756
Ellafella

I haven't seen anything yet to suggest he isn't capable of doing a great job in a very tough division.

Oh dear, "hate" is a strong word & at no point have I espoused hatred for PC. Please allow me to qualify my view;
It's early days and PC has lost some top class players: Hughes and Bryson and Thorne intermittently. Because of their absence the team has lost the midfield CPU if you like for those players are what makes the team tick. As long-standing fans, we know how any replacement for those players should work - most importantly how to feed Christopher Martin into feet and how to have Ince and Russell feeding off. Yet that hasn't happened. The only time we saw that was against Leeds in the first 10 minutes of the 2nd half. So, that has cas

[ellafella]

I can.....warnock played well on Saturday, certainly better than christie did against burnley who wasted everything that came to him. People bummed christie and slated warnock, some clueless people gave him 3/10!! What a joke. Minds are made up on him and he's too old and not the future.

I gave him 3/10 because that's how I saw his performance ... I cant justify giving him another 3 marks just because he made a decent cross to Johnson..
So we dont agree.. Well there is a surprise.. Clueless? Feck off.
[/quote]

The ball across was sublime Angry...it set up the goal, was an "assist" and was a significant factor in us winning the game. QED Warnock, the architect of the goal, deserved 6/10...3 of which were given for that cross. It's passes like that which win games.

[Rapid]

[quote="Bear DCFC"]The decision that confused me was the keeper, Carson dropped for one game when he made no mistakes, only to be restored a game later. The Warnock/Forsyth rotation is less surprising to me, we see it in the Prem so why not the Championship? Most agree that Warnock had his best game in a Derby shirt. I'd be more concerned if he was swapping CBs every game. It tells me that he's a thoughtful coach who knows how to pick a team to win - recent results confirm that.

Rapid - you posted a couple weeks ago that you've seen enough of Clement's Derby to know that he isn;t going to get us promoted. I was surprised to read that post from you as you're normally a lot more rational. I think this is the kind of comment which is unhelpful and in hindsight perhaps you regret? I don't know, maybe you don't. I just think we owe it to everyone concerned to give him time, some read these types of comments and carry them onto Twitter, which the coach/pla