How do you measure self-defence?
When self-defence is relied upon it is for the court to make a factual finding of what actually happened and then make an assessment of whether the defendant's actions were reasonable. That will be a jury of 12 in more serious cases and a District Judge or two or more lay magistrates in the Magistrates Court. The idea is that they apply the views of society of what is reasonable.
But yes, every time a court reaches a verdict it is an expression of opinion. I don't see any viable alternative, but that's why I don't and never will support the death penalty.



Reply With Quote
