Keogh / Shackell

[Manofpride]

Keogh to Burnley for £1.5million.

Would you swap Keogh for Jason Shackell???

[Rapid]

shackell is a better player, no doubt about that but he's getting on a bit now isn't he?

[Manofpride]

shackell is a better player, no doubt about that but he's getting on a bit now isn't he?

Agreed but would you do a straight swap!

[sheeeeeeeeeep]

Yes, then we would have Shotton at right CB and Shackell at left CB.

[RamFromCornwall]

Shackell is a month off 31, Keogh has only just turned 28, so pretty much a three year difference. Not sure I would do a straight swap but I would rather have Shackell.

[Stan_van_nel]

The way Shackell has started off this season, I'd be a better bet alongside Keogh.

[Rapid]

shackell is a better player, no doubt about that but he's getting on a bit now isn't he?

Agreed but would you do a straight swap![/quote]

probably not because of the age thing.

[Popsidepaul]

Keogh to Burnley for £1.5million.

Would you swap Keogh for Jason Shackell???

Yes, JC the better player.

[Popsidepaul]

Keogh to Burnley for £1.5million.

Would you swap Keogh for Jason Shackell???

Yes, JC the better player.[/quote]

Meant to say JS, but JC was also pretty useful too apparently...

[lancyclaret]

Shackell is the better player - do not want Keogh at Burnley.