Season ratings

[jvmiller]

Here's how the Millers players rated over the season, ranging from 9/10 to 4/10. Do you agree with them?
- view external link

[gwru]

Knock Kelly down to 7, a full back has got to be able to get forward.

Ofoe up to 8 he helped us get 6pts.

Hyam up to a 7 rated him.

G Ward up to 8 our main outlet.

Newell up to 7 got some scope, alot to work with there.

Managers:

Evans 5

Black 4

Redfearn 3

Warnock 10

[millertop]

I like Broadfoot & Kelly but can't understand giving them 8 then only giving G Ward 7, Newell 6 (who has been carrying an injury)

Danny Collins a 5 is very generous

[millers88]

Kelly a 6 for me 8 too high
Collins a 4 at best, worst centre half ive ever seen in a millers shirt
Hyam up 1 to a 6, thought he looked steady in midfield and good passer of the ball
Ledesma a 4 is tiny bit harsh, scored a winning goal at home to Cardiff in only the handful of games, id say 5
Barker a 4 is also harsh after scoring a wonderful strike on his debut and hardly featured at all after that, a baffling decision by Neil Redfearn
Best from 7 to 6, apart from the home game against Derby where he scored 2 ***** goals to get us a draw, ive not been that impress by him, not as much as the other fans anyways and shouldnt be rated higher than JCH who has scored more.

[Mandy_Turnerhead]

Really good summary, that. Not much to argue with.

Like a couple have said, I think G Ward could possibly be bumped up a grade, just because of how crucial his pace and, to quote Redfearn, ability to get up the field quickly has been to us. I completely agree he is frustrating but in a team which is otherwise stagnant he's been so important.

I agree that Collins should only be a 4 - as painfully destructive to our defence as Roos in those opening games, I'd say.

Would agree with the poor ratings for Hyam and Ledesma - exactly the kind of players you don't need in a relegation scrap and it told.

[gorky]

Stephen Kelly has been excellent since Warnock came in, deserves the 8. I'd knock Best and JCH down a grade though. JV's list is a great reminder of some of the sh*te we've watched this season.