Derek McInnes

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by afc1903mad

You think so.
The general consensus is that he beats the lower placed teams and struggles in the top 6.
There is a minimum of 11 games left this season, so your predicting McInnes wont win 55% of the games he has potentially left.
Given his win rate is circa 56% since he joined Aberdeen, it's not a stretch to consider it may be tough to win more than his average, given we play 5 of those games post split against the top half.

Our next 6 games are all winnable.
Partick Thistle at home
Kilmarnock away (cup replay)
Dundee at home
St Johnstone at home
Motherwell away
Hearts away.

It's entirely possible we would win 4 of those and maybe draw a couple (Motherwell and Hearts away).
We then have the split, so possible to beat Kilmarnock, Hearts and Hibs

I get what your saying though, it's a pretty easy statement to make.
If your being so generous, how many wins do you think he will get?

---

I told you...below 6. I think we will struggle again at the weekend and unfortunately I don’t see us progressing against Kilmarnock in the cup.
For what it’s worth I really hope we win the Scottish Cup and win all our remaining matches. I can’t see any of that happening and let’s be honest, is there any Dons fan that thinks we will win the Scottish Cup?
McInnes as you well know is struggling at this time and this is when we will truly get an insight into how he performs under real pressure. The man says he has ambition so let’s see it then Derek. Ambitious teams don’t accept defeat easily.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by afc1903mad

It is a tough one, I do think Jones won the penalty kick by going down and there was contact after.
The thing is as a defender, you can't make any contact in the box, else there is an argument for the pen.
Jones did we'll to get in front of Logan and ensure contact was made and obvious.

The Christie / Brophey claim was much harder to see and definitely at first glance in real time, would not have appeared that there was any contact from Christie and just a fresh air swipe by Brophey

---

I am sticking up for Del on the argument about Jones and that penalty. It was a dive all day long.
Christie was extremely lucky as that one was a penalty.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RED_JOHN

I told you...below 6. I think we will struggle again at the weekend and unfortunately I don’t see us progressing against Kilmarnock in the cup.
For what it’s worth I really hope we win the Scottish Cup and win all our remaining matches. I can’t see any of that happening and let’s be honest, is there any Dons fan that thinks we will win the Scottish Cup?
McInnes as you well know is struggling at this time and this is when we will truly get an insight into how he performs under real pressure. The man says he has ambition so let’s see it then Derek. Ambitious teams don’t accept defeat easily.

---

Do I think we will win the Scottish cup?, probably not.
Do I think we have a chance and are capable of getting to the final? Definately
Once your in the final, anything can happen, so its still a possibility.

I think realistically, we'll get at least 5 or 6 wins for the remainder of the season.
The cup games remain the higher importance.

One game at a time though, a win on Saturday, coupled with a defeat of SevCo on Sunday means we are just three points behind them with a game in hand.
Hearts to beat Hibs on Friday would make it a perfect weekend.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RED_JOHN

I am sticking up for Del on the argument about Jones and that penalty. It was a dive all day long.
Christie was extremely lucky as that one was a penalty.

---

I can see why the ref gave them as he did and discounted the Christie pen claim.
It was a pen for the Jones dive though as technically there was contact from Logan in the box.

So every time there is "contact" it's a foul?

When did fitba stop being a contact sport?

F u c k me, this "contact" p!sh is the type of sharn spouted by hand-jobs like Andy Walker and Billy Dodds.

Going down when you feel "contact" is cheating, end of story.

And any justification of it is just modern fitba fannyb@baws c u n t ishness.

He took advantage of some appalling defending. In proper mannies fitba it’s never a penalty but with the standard of our refs, you’re always likely to be giving one away,

McInnes wouldn’t need to have mentioned it if him & the players did their jobs well. It’s deflection

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by InversneckieDob

So every time there is "contact" it's a foul?

When did fitba stop being a contact sport?

F u c k me, this "contact" p!sh is the type of sharn spouted by hand-jobs like Andy Walker and Billy Dodds.

Going down when you feel "contact" is cheating, end of story.

And any justification of it is just modern fitba fannyb@baws c u n t ishness.

---

Depends on the type of contact.
You're allowed contact with the opposition i.e. shoulder to shoulder, but you can't clip the legs of a player running into the box (or indeed anywhere on the pitch)
Jones had the advantage as he came across Logan, at that point, Logan needed to adjust his run to stop going through the back of the diving Jones.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by afc1903mad

Logan needed to adjust his run to stop going through the back of the diving Jones.

---

As you state, Jones dived. Never a penalty, the referee got it wrong again for that decision.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by InversneckieDob

Why is that relevant?

Why?

---

The relevance is that McInnes's position is that there was no contact. That was clearly not the case. As I said it looked a possibility that the boy was going down prior to Logan running into the back of him. In that case its definitely not a pen. I agree that it is not a non contact sport but if the referee deems a player has impeded another by running into the back of him then he is entitled to give a pen.

For what its worth I think Jones probably dived.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kigoretrout

The relevance is that McInnes's position is that there was no contact. That was clearly not the case. As I said it looked a possibility that the boy was going down prior to Logan running into the back of him. In that case its definitely not a pen. I agree that it is not a non contact sport but if the referee deems a player has impeded another by running into the back of him then he is entitled to give a pen.

For what its worth I think Jones probably dived.

---

So that probably means there was no contact immediately prior to the foul which I suppose is what Deek was saying ! Feck knows !