Next manager

[offshore_arab83]

i know its only your gut feel but your gut feel on csaba was good. I will back anyone but like yerself i have a reservation here but also can see it working. depends on how he adapts and how quickly.

to be fair mate everyone was happy wi the appointment of the clown due to how he had hearts playing, how wrong were we all...

[Shedboy1971]

to be fair mate everyone was happy wi the appointment of the clown due to how he had hearts playing, how wrong were we all...

yeah i know - suppose we can never predict success of a manager at a club. I will give Mellon the benefit of the doubt simply because of his attitude BUT this is a much bigger club with much more pressure than he is used to. Thats what he will need to handle.

[tHeArAb]

Great article by Stevie Banks.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.the...s-manager/amp/

[cybershed]

yeah i know - suppose we can never predict success of a manager at a club. I will give Mellon the benefit of the doubt simply because of his attitude BUT this is a much bigger club with much more pressure than he is used to. Thats what he will need to handle.

I think the pressure managers face in Scotland can come as a surprise to some.

But I think Micky Mellons is probably just at the right stage of his managerial trajectory to take us on.

McLaren and Wright have achieved everything they are going to as managers. Their managerial stars are well on the wane.

Malky is a rehabilitation job, and a risk.

As for Badger, big Jon et al - this is not a job for a rookie.

The more I think about it, the more I like the idea of Micky Mellons.

[Arabdownsouth]

yeah i know - suppose we can never predict success of a manager at a club. I will give Mellon the benefit of the doubt simply because of his attitude BUT this is a much bigger club with much more pressure than he is used to. Thats what he will need to handle.

On this basis I don't see the argument in favour of Tommy Wright

[Jim_Jam]

My last comment regarding this, GB do you think you would feel the same way about Malky if you happened to be black, Chinese or gay Same question applies to all of those clamouring for his appointment. Why can't people just accept that the club have chosen to protect their image at a time where its a very prominent issue for society. Malky was in no way guaranteed to succeed so just not worth the risk. Onwards and upwards please gents

If a managerial candidate was black, Chinese or gay and had a proven successful Premier league record I would welcome him to Dundee United with open arms. Perhaps its because I am more interested in the footballing side of things than the colour of their skin or for that matter if someone made several wrong comments in a text messages in 2013.

[A. J]

Personally didn't want Wright or any of the rookies but whoever it is i will trust that the club are looking to continue with the upward trend since their arrival.
Reading the Trannere forum it seems some poster thinks this is done and will be announced later today (rumours I know)
As for the Malky episode my point in a previous rant was for fans to support the decision made by the club whether he got appointed or not, its up to the club to contemplate any pros and cons of any new recruit
sending emails is out of line.

[Arabdownsouth]

If a managerial candidate was black, Chinese or gay and had a proven successful Premier league record I would welcome him to Dundee United with open arms. Perhaps its because I am more interested in the footballing side of things than the colour of their skin or for that matter if someone made several wrong comments in a text messages in 2013.

You need to read my post properly 👍

[Jim_Jam]

You need to read my post properly ��

Oops your right - sorry. I didn't read it properly.

If he was picking me in his team for footballing reasons. FINE.
If I wasn't being picked? Would I think I wasn't being picked because of non-footballing reasons? PROBLEM. (I might blame that on any manager - I am great but..... I'm not being picked for some other reason .....).

I do get your point though.

[Arabdownsouth]

So I did - sorry

If he was picking me in his team for footballing reasons. FINE.
If I wasn't being picked? Would I think I wasn't being picked because of non-footballing reasons? PROBLEM. (I might blame that on any manager - I am great but..... I'm not being picked for some other reason .....).

I do get your point though.

No worries, it's like I've said just not worth the bother. I care a hell of a lot more about Dundee United than I do about Malky Mackay.